Vol 31, No 3 (2026): POSTMODERNISM: PRO ET CONTRA
- Year: 2026
- Articles: 21
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/literary-criticism/issue/view/2172
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2312-9220-2026-31-3
Full Issue
EDITORIA
539-548
LITERARY CRITICISM
Overcoming Modernism and Postmodernism: Paradoxes of Subjectivity in Anna Akhmatova’s Poem Without a Hero
Abstract
This article examines the subject organization of Anna Akhmatova’s Poem Without a Hero in its late editorial phase, dating from 1963 to 1965. Drawing on the framing prose passages, stage directions and key episodes, the analysis demonstrates that the poem simultaneously decentralizes the subject while ultimately reasserting its unity. Alien voices, masks, and intertextual “roles” create an effect of polyphony; however, this polyphony proves illusory, since it is entirely regulated by the author-subject, who demonstratively controls the entrance and exit of voices and establishes the boundaries of interpretation. The author is shown to assume several roles simultaneously: creator and director of the textual and performative space; lyrical persona and participant in the events; commentator and textual scholar of her own work; a historiosophical thinker who projects the private plot onto a historical perspective; and a judge who assumes the role of a collective arbiter. At the same time, the author is not merely the director of this drama of voices but is herself incorporated into the choral space. This determines the distinctive subjectivity of Poem Without a Hero: on the one hand, the authorial voice appears to dissolve into the choral whole; on the other, it may itself become objectified in external phenomena, as though transferring the right to speak to the elements of nature and to the text of the poem itself. The article concludes that the subjectivity of “Poem Without a Hero” cannot be reduced to modernist masking and does not coincide with the postmodernist “death of the author”. Rather, the poem presents an integrative model of subjectivity in which the external carnival of discourses turns into an instrument of a single author’s center of memory and responsibility.
549-561
L. Petrushevskaya’s Story From the Mountain: System of Images, Narrative Strategies in a Postmodern Text
Abstract
The article offers a new interpretation of L. Petrushevskaya’s short story From the Mountain. he structural and thematic emphases previously placed on the text by critics and literary scholars are revised. In particular, the character system and narrative strategies in the story are considered from a new point of view. While earlier critics based their analysis on the characters of ‘He’ and ‘She’, placing their love story at the center of scholarly discourse, this article proposes a different approach. Instead of focusing on these two figures, it examines the narrator-heroine, a witness to the love story of vacationers, as presented by her from a highly subjective perspective. The paper challenges the notion that the author’s position and that of the narrator-heroine are identical, proving that the narrator cannot be considered the author’s alter ego. It is demonstrated that the linguistic and stylistic features of the narrator-observer’s evaluative statements serve as a means of portraying the protagonist, shaping her persona and image. The article concludes that there are multifaceted vectors for expressing the author’s position, highlighting the presence of the “zero degree of writing” (Roland Barthes) in Petrushevskaya’s postmodern narrative.
562-574
The Subject in Mikhail Elizarov’s Lyrics: Deconstruction or Reconstruction?
Abstract
The article examines the poetics of literary postmodernism in the context of defining the specificity of this movement. The empirical material of the study is the lyric poetry of Mikhail Yelizarov. The choice of the research material is motivated by the potential to problematize the status of postmodernism: on the one hand, Yelizarov’s work is interpreted by literary scholars and critics within postmodernist frameworks; on the other hand, Yelizarov himself rejects postmodernism as an ontological phenomenon, reducing it to a problem of reception. The paper demonstrates that, when examined typologically, a postmodernist text at the level of poetics manifests a system of philosophical ideas, the central one being the idea of the dissolution of the subject. It is argued that this idea determines the specificity of all artistic components within the field of subjectivity and personality and underpins the main strategies of postmodernist writing. Specifically, the disintegration of the narrator and the protagonist leads to the collapse of narrative structures and the neutralization of evaluative perspective, which in turn results in the apologia of intertextuality and a specific type of irony. At the formal level, Yelizarov’s poetic oeuvre employs certain strategies conventionally associated with postmodernism. However, as the study shows, this formal complex is underpinned by an entirely different system of meanings, the foundation of which is an integral subject.
575-587
Posthumous Narration as a Marker of Postmodern Aesthetics in Contemporary Uzbek Literature
Abstract
The article examines the problems of identifying modern Uzbek literature in the context of the “postmodern situation” (J. Lyotard), which has determined a number of conceptual trends in the post-Soviet development of national literatures during the shift of the artistic paradigm in the 1990s. The authors identify the most obvious constants and markers that determined the inclusion of the aesthetic constants of literary postmodernism in the works of the most iconic Uzbek writers of the non-classical artistic paradigm. The purpose of the article is to identify, define, and theoretically substantiate the worldview and aesthetic dominants of postum narrative, which demonstrate the functioning of postmodernism as a type of artistic consciousness, method, and style of the national literary system of Uzbekistan. The scientific novelty of the work lies not only in the systematic analysis of literary works based on the methodology and theory of postmodernism, but also in the development of identification criteria for relating ethno-cultural texts to the worldview, world-modeling, and aesthetic principles of postmodernism. The authors analyze the general constants of the postmodern type of artistic consciousness, but they focus on postum narrative as a strategy for the specific organization of postmodern literary texts and a marker of the “world as a text” model. This type of narrative determines the poetics, methods of world-modeling, and representation of ethno-cultural identity in a number of works by contemporary authors with a pronounced postmodern aesthetic. The research material comprises the Uzbek-language novel To’rt tomon qibla (Four Directions of the World) by Aman Mukhtar and the Russian-language novel Mbobo by Khamid Ismailov, a transcultural author associated with the Uzbek underground and literary diaspora. The methodological framework of the study employs intertextual and narrative analysis, alongside receptive and hermeneutic approaches to the interpretation of cultural codes and ciphers. It has been established that in the contemporary Uzbek literary process, postmodernism functions not as a distinct literary movement, but as a variable manifestation of its principles and trends within individual literary works. These works feature a pronounced metafictional architectonics of the “world as text”, which structures both the stylistic (intertextual and hypertextual levels) and structural principles of text construction (the narrative level).
588-604
“I Am”: The Affirmation of Personality in S.N. Durylin’s Artistic World
Abstract
The article reveals the worldview features in the literary oeuvre of S.N. Durylin (1886-1954), who was a writer, priest, theologian, teacher and theater scholar. The purpose of the work is to describe the process of affirming personal existence in the writer’s artistic world. To this end, the following tasks are addressed: the biblical tradition of expressing the name of God in the Old and New Testaments is analyzed; the connection between Durylin’s “I am” and Holy Scripture is described; and the “paschal potential” of S.N. Durylin’s literary texts is revealed based on the story On Someone Else’s Grave. Despite the value crises of the 20th century, the writer’s warm literary preserve the “paschal experience” imprinted in his soul since childhood. The study concludes that Gospel revelations, which disclose the divine essence, are directly related to the existence of the individual and the attainment of inner integrity. It is established that in S.N. Durylin’s artistic world “ontological anxiety” is overcome by the individual through the acquisition of faith and spiritual and moral effort based on remembrance: “I remember, therefore I exist...” - which serves as an immutable law of being. As a result, it is demonstrated that remembrance for S.N. Durylin has a “paschal” nature, is linked to eternity and “life-giving memory”, and is capable of harmonizing “human fragmentation”.
605-615
The Myth of St. Petersburg in the Mirror of Modern Literature
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to systematically describe of the transition of the St. Petersburg text from a living literary tradition to a hypertrophied, fragmentary, and self-reflexive mythological code. The question of how political cataclysms (revolutions, blockades, the renaming of the city) and the change of place names transformed the archaic myth had not previously been addressed comprehensively: studies either focused on the classics of the 19th century or identified individual postmodern techniques without connection to the archaic stratum. The scholarly contribution of this work lies in identifying the stable structure of the “archetype of death”, which remains stable across ideological shifts and becomes the core of Russian cultural identity. The article contains sections devoted to the theory of the St. Petersburg text, examination of political upheavals as catalysts for the transformation of the St. Petersburg text, and comparison of key mythemes (of water and death). The research methodology included comparative analysis of the corpus of texts, and semiotic deconstruction of recurring narrative nodes. St. Petersburg in modern literature is not a topos, but an operator of cultural memory; the myth of the city has outlived its referent and turned into an autonomous generator of meanings. The resulting model can serve as a tool for deciphering other “urban texts” of Russian culture.
616-625
The Comic in the Artistic Anthropology of V.V. Veresaev’s Works
Abstract
The sources of the comic effect in the literary works of V.V. Veresaev have scarcely been studied and therefore require systematic scholarly investigation. The purpose of this article is to analyze the functions of the techniques and devices used to create a comic effect within the artistic anthropology of Veresaev’s prose. The study demonstrates that the principal source of the comic effect in Veresaev’s works lies in the portraits of literary characters. These portraits form a system in which each element manifests a specific character trait of the character. The poetics of the comic in Veresaev’s writing is realized in either a humorous or a satirical mode. Satire constructs a form of negative artistic anthropology, while the objects of satirical ridicule are depicted through aggressive rhetorical strategies. Humor, in contrast, produces a more benevolent rhetorical perspective toward the characters. Both the physical and inner qualities of the characters are actively involved in the creation of the comic effect. To achieve the desired artistic result, the author transforms elements of portrait description - either by hyperbolizing or reducing particular features. This transformation creates the conditions necessary for the emergence of the comic effect. Each component of the literary portrait of a satirical or humorous character functions as a sign carrying a specific semantic dimension of the comic. Humorous and satirical contexts thus concretize and give visible form to the artistic anthropology of Veresaev’s prose. The elements of the comic impart a realistic character to the artistic anthropology of Veresaev’s works.
626-635
The Genesis, Realization, and Function of Two Types of Defamiliarization in V.N. Nekrasov’s Poetry of the 1960s
Abstract
The relevance of this article is determined by the importance of the role that the poet V.N. Nekrasov played in Russian literature between the 1950s and the 2000s, as well as the need to clarify and add complexity to the picture of Russian unofficial literature of the second half of the 20th century. The purpose of this article is to describe one of the initial stages of Nekrasov’s creative evolution. His acquaintance with and subsequent joining of the in Lianozovo Group in the late autumn of 1959 led to an intensification of the concretist element in his work, which had developed in the mid-1950s. The novelty of the article lies in the definition of Nekrasov’s creative innovations in the poetry of the 1960s as the realization of two types of defamiliarization of the word. The first was historically rooted in the device of lexical repetition and involved immersing the word in numerous consonances, attractions, and contexts. The second one, on the contrary, entailed a minimalistic absorption the word across the space of the book page. Both types of defamiliarization led to the deautomatization of everyday speech and the discovery of a creative principle potentially inherent in every word. At the same time, these approaches not only did not contradict each other, but harmoniously coexisted both in one literary text and in the context of a poetry collection. The result of the research is the identification of the mechanism of Nekrasov’s creative evolution. By the end of the 1960s and the beginning of the 1970s, the developed types of defamiliarization of the word led to the actualization of the pragmatic aspect and to Nekrasov’s own understanding of the literary text as an act. In addition, the analyzed types of defamiliarization make it possible to identify Nekrasov’s more general aesthetic principles, particularly his belief in the creative potential of every word, which distinguished Nekrasov from some other Moscow unofficial poets.
636-646
Initiation as a Plot-Forming Element of M. Elizarov’s Novels
Abstract
The article examines the concept of initiation, which is analyzed in detail in the works of traditionalist thinkers (R. Guénon, J. Evola, M. Eliade) and plays a plot-forming role in many works of the contemporary Russian writer M. Elizarov. The aim is to explain the place that initiation occupies in the novels of the author. The task is to analyze the specific forms that it takes in these novels. The thesis is put forward that initiation is understood by Elizarov as the character’s existential transition from a profane (ordinary) state to a sacred (magical) one. This transition is a staged process and can be undergone by the character either completely or partially. The actual magical initiation is preceded by a warrior one, and the acceptance of military initiation is impossible without previous marginalization, which is not an immediate part of the initiatory process, but serves as its necessary prerequisite. Although initiation is a process that takes place “inside” a person, it cannot be carried out without performing special actions - rituals. The initiatory rites featured in Elizarov’s novels serve similar functions, but have a large number of formal differences, each of which is also discussed in the article.
647-657
L.N. Tolstoy in the Creative Perception of Abai and Shakarim: An Ethical Dialogue
Abstract
The article examines the reception of L.N. Tolstoy’s ethical ideas in Kazakh literature of the late 19th - early 20th centuries through the works of Abai Kunanbaev and Shakarim Kudaiberdiev. Special attention is paid to the comparison of the concepts of “moral regeneration” and “conscience” in Tolstoy’s later writings and in Kudaiberdiev’s philosophical treatise Three Truths. Methodologically, the study is based on comparative-historical and hermeneutic approaches, which make it possible to reveal not only typological convergences but also cultural and religious differences in the interpretation of universal ethical categories. The analysis shows that Shakarim, unlike Abai, entered into a more direct and deliberate with Tolstoy, reinterpreting his ideas through the lens of the Kazakh Sufi tradition. The key concept of this reinterpretation is “uzhdan” (Kazakh for “conscience”, Russian: “sovest’”), which in Shakarim’s philosophy acquires the significance of a universal criterion for the immortality of the soul. The article contributes to the study of intercultural literary connections and may be useful for specialists in comparative literary studies, as well as for researchers of Russian-Kazakh literary relations.
658-666
JOURNALISM
Social Mandate for Journalism: Perceptions and Assessments of Regional Journalists
Abstract
This study examines regional journalists’ perceptions of the social mandate for journalism, using the Voronezh region as a case study. Based on an empirical sociological study comprising 38 qualitative semi-structured interviews, the research explores the structure, manifestations, and variability of the social mandate. It also analyzes the mandate’s connection to journalism education and identifies the conditions for its implementation in regional media. The findings indicate that the social mandate is primarily realized through analytical reporting and special media projects. Furthermore, the study reveals that journalists perceive this mandate as shaped by a combination of societal needs and state demands. Key barriers to implementation include staffing shortages, financial constraints, and time limitations. The paper concludes by outlining future research directions and offering recommendations for advancing media education and optimizing interactions among the regional press, government authorities, and the local community.
667-681
Media Image of an Industrial Region: Dominant Themes and Stereotypes
Abstract
This study presents the results of research on the media image of the Chelyabinsk industrial region in the context of dominant themes and stereotypes. The aim is to identify the main topics of the media agenda in regional mass media outlets “74.ru” and “1obl.ru” for 2025 and to systematize the stereotypes that shape the media image of the territory. The choice of research object is motivated by the need to bridge the gap between the actual development of Chelyabinsk and its representation in the media. The thematic structure serves as an indicator of editorial attention, while stereotypes function as a tool for meaning construction. The empirical base consists of 35,575 media texts processed using the API-Monitoring system. Quantitative and qualitative content analysis methods were employed, grounded in agenda-setting theory (at the thematic and attribute levels). The editorial policies of both outlets and the dynamics of positive, negative, and neutral stereotype framing were compared. The results reveal that the leading positions in the media agenda of “74.ru” are occupied by topics related to the social sphere, history, culture, and economic potential, with the outlet demonstrating a predominance of negative tone (54.8%), whereas “1obl.ru” focuses on a neutral-to-positive tone (73.1%). The study establishes that the media space of the Chelyabinsk region exhibits a stable trend of transforming negative stereotypes (“harsh industrial zone”, “black sky conditions”) into positive images of a technologically progressive and socially comfortable territory.
682-696
Transforming Host Discourse in Makeover Shows: From Normative Conformity to the Legitimization of Individuality
Abstract
This study examines conceptual shifts in the discursive practices of hosts in American makeover shows, capturing a transition from normative conformity to the legitimization of individuality. A comparative analysis is conducted on two projects featuring the same hosts - Stacy London and Clinton Kelly - across different media eras: the linear television series What Not to Wear (2003-2013, 248 episodes) and the streaming project Wear Whatever the F You Want (2025, 8 episodes). Qualitative discourse analysis, focusing on pragmatic goals, interactional tactics, and the coordination of verbal and non-verbal cues, reveals stable communicative patterns rather than mere statistical frequencies. The findings show that the earlier project was dominated by an authoritarian discourse, operationalized through tactics of negative evaluation, accusations, and mockery, thereby reinforcing external aesthetic standards. The 2025 project, in contrast, exhibits a cooperative communicative orientation grounded in empathy, respect for individual choice, and the deconstruction of rigid stylistic norms. The asymmetry of the empirical base - due to the incomplete corpus of the streaming project at its initial release - did not compromise the validity of the findings, thanks to the achieved data saturation. These results contribute to understanding how platformization and cultural shifts transform host-participant interaction in reality TV formats, with implications for media ethics, inclusive representation, and the evolving pragmatics of entertainment discourse.
697-709
Reuters Institute Annual Reports as a Form of Media Industry Foresight: Epistemological Foundations and Limitations
Abstract
The article examines the annual Journalism, Media, and Technology Trends and Predictions reports of the Reuters Institute as a specific form of knowledge production about the media industry. The relevance of the study is driven by the widespread use of these reports in both academic and applied research, particularly against the backdrop of a scarcity of theoretical frameworks in journalism studies and a growing demand for rapid, industry-oriented guidance. The aim of the article is to identify the methodological foundations and epistemological limitations of these reports. The empirical basis of the study is a corpus of publications from 2012 to 2026. The methodological approach combines qualitative discourse analysis and comparative analysis to reconstruct the research model, sample composition, and implicit theoretical assumptions. The study demonstrates that the Reuters Institute reports rely on a reproducible yet structurally constrained model of expert surveys, characterized by a bias toward top-level Western media executives and a weak representation of peripheral media systems. In the absence of explicit theoretical reflection, these reports function as carriers of an implicit theory grounded in assumptions of “soft” technological determinism and an industry-centered understanding of journalism. The article argues that these reports do not simply describe the state of the media industry, but actively construct the horizons of its conceivable development, normalizing professional expectations and operating as an instrument of the collective imagination of journalism’s future. The article concludes that such materials should be used critically in academic research and journalism education, with a clear distinction between their status as sources of expert opinion and as tools of empirical foresight.
710-722
Media-Geographical Analysis of the Semantic Space of International Conflicts and Crises
Abstract
This article explores the semantic space of international conflicts and crises from a media-geographical perspective. The relevance of this work stems from the growing role of semantic and value factors in the dynamics of contemporary conflicts, which increasingly unfold not only in physical but also in symbolic space. The theoretical and methodological framework of the study draws on a media-geographical approach to analyzing mental landscapes in different countries. Big data analysis was conducted through the integration of rank, factor, and content analysis within a spatiotemporal framework. The study revealed consistent country and regional patterns: the dominance of requests for “good” in the countries of the Middle East and North Africa, as well as in Russia and India; a concentration of interest in “freedom” in conflict-ridden and unstable regions; a fivefold global excess of requests for “security” over requests for “freedom”; and a correlation between the theme of “injustice” and the zone of permanent crisis in the Middle East. The results confirmed the thesis that value dichotomies act as markers of the conflictogenic potential of mental landscapes.
723-735
Media as a Factor in the Formation of Catalan National Consciousness
Abstract
Globalization and the establishment of a unified information space significantly blur national boundaries. Nevertheless, the geopolitical realities of both the 20th and the 21st centuries demonstrate that it is nationalist ideas that have become the main point of reference for many political movements. These ideas and images, reproduced on a large scale by the mass media and aimed at constructing national identity, are widespread in contemporary society. This article examines the formation of Catalan national identity through the lens of Catalan media of the 19th-21st centuries. Drawing on an analysis of scholarly literature and journalistic sources, the author traces the evolution of the Catalan press from a vehicle for the cultural revival of the Catalan language to an instrument of political mobilization during the 2017 crisis. Special attention is paid to the bilingual nature of the press - one of the key features of Catalan journalism, which directly affects national self-awareness. The author concludes that the region’s media system is distinctly national in orientation and functions as a key institution of socialization, preserving the uniqueness of the language and constructing the image of a “victim nation” in opposition to the Spanish state.
736-748
Artificial Intelligence and Human: A Comparative Analysis of Scientific Review Articles
Abstract
This article presents an experiment comparing the quality of scientific review articles written by humans and by three large language models (LLM) - ChatGPT-4o, Gemini Flash 2.0, T-Lite - technologies commonly referred to as artificial intelligence (AI). As AI is rapidly integrated into academia, the issue of distinguishing between machine-generated and human-written texts is becoming critical. The author generated three review articles on the topic “Development of deep learning methods” (20,000 characters each) and compared them with a fragment of his own PhD thesis of the same length, as well as with a “mock” text imitating a scientific review. Four AI domain experts and three LLMs served as evaluators. The results showed that the text generated by Gemini Flash 2.0 ranked first in total scores for both groups of evaluators, while the human-written text ranked third. Experts assigned a 78% probability to the hypothesis that the human text was machine-generated, indicating that they could not reliably identify it as human-authored. The hypothesis that the human text would outperform the LLM texts and be unambiguously identifiable was not supported. The article concludes that modern AI systems can produce scientific reviews comparable in quality to those written by humans and that are difficult to distinguish from them, necessitating a revision of academic writing and peer review practices.
749-761
Trolling of Chatbots as a Response to Neurocommenting and an Indicator of the Crisis of Interactivity
Abstract
This article examines neurocommenting - a contemporary and insufficiently studied phenomenon emerging in online user environments. The growing popularization of artificial intelligence and the reluctance of most users to communicate with bots necessitate conducting informal “Turing tests” to identify robotic authorship. Such attempts lead to another unusual phenomenon: users trolling chatbots. Based on an analysis of 287 bot comments from ten chats, bot comments and user reactions to them were classified. A brief periodization of neurocommenting development and various objectives of clients commissioning this service are presented. The results demonstrate that a quarter of users tend to ignore bots. The majority (38%) of those who respond to bots wish to know who is a robot and who is human. Every third reaction is emotional and constitutes trolling of the bot; every fifth contains a demand to block the bot. However, only a small minority (7%) are willing to communicate with robots. It is likely that in the near future, if platform owners do not develop effective anti-bot filtering systems, we will arrive at either full-fledged human-bot communication or the loss of interactivity as a crucial component of the modern media system.
762-773
The Politics of Fat Representation and Digital Media Discourse in Kate Stayman-London’s One to Watch: A Review Article
Abstract
This review article examines the representation of fatness and digital media discourse in Kate Stayman-London’s novel One to Watch (2020). The study synthesises existing research on fat representation in media, digital body surveillance, and affective economies to explore how contemporary fiction engages with and critiques the stigmatisation of plus-size bodies in a media-saturated world. Using critical discourse analysis (CDA) as a methodological framework, the review identifies four recurring media frames within the novel: medicalisation of fatness, sexual objectification, moral condemnation, and spectacular disgust. The analysis demonstrates that Stayman-London’s multimodal narrative - incorporating tweets, blog posts, online headlines, and comments - not only reproduces real-world digital harassment but also constructs counter-discourses of vulnerability and resilience. The review concludes that One to Watch serves as a transformative cultural artefact that archives contemporary bodily autonomy and offers a literary intervention into media-driven body politics. The findings contribute to ongoing discussions in media studies, cultural journalism, and Fat Studies by showing how fictional narratives can illuminate the mechanisms of online stigmatisation and resistance.
774-784
INTERVIEW OF THE ISSUE
785-795








