Vol 23, No 3 (2024): Ethnicity and Power in Russia: History and Modernity

ETHNICITY AND POWER IN RUSSIA: HISTORY AND MODERNITY

Balkan Colonists in the Azov Region: Diversity of Identities and Demise of the Ethnic Paradigm

Novik A.A.

Abstract

Through his work, the author analyzes the influence of state ideology and cultural codes on the ethnic and national self-identification of the migrants from Southeastern Europe to the Azov region of Russia. Through his research, he has revealed the degree of influence of various factors contributing to the sustainable preservation or loss of ethnic, regional, linguistic and religious identities within the framework of the development of a separate multi-ethnic territory. The source base for the study is the documents of the State Archive of the Rostov Region and the materials of complex expeditions, the Archive of the Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography of the Russian Academy of Sciences. The author comes to the conclusion, that at the present, most residents of the villages on the shores of the Taganrog Bay are well aware of the history of their settlements; many are ready to claim that they have Greek/ Arnaut roots, and therefore they resolutely declare their “autochthony.” However, there are no attempts to revitalize this traditional culture or it’s holidays - “like in Greece or Albania” (as it is happening in the Zaporozhye and Donetsk regions). In the region, belonging to one’s people, by those born and living there, is perceived as a more significant marker than ethnic origin, ethnic self-identification and declaration of ethnic preferences.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):260-271
pages 260-271 views

Administrative and Police Regulation of Muslim Women’s Position in Russian Turkestan

Litvinov V.P.

Abstract

The author considers in two contexts the problem of the legal regulation of Muslim women’s position in Russian Turkestan, the Central Asia territories which had become part of Russia - on the one hand, the general state of the women's issue in the Russian Empire, and on the other hand, how the state ensured the rights of the entire local population of the region. Within the text, the role of the imperial police in regulating the legal status of Muslim women is examined. It is emphasized that in various regions of Russia the position of women had its own regional specifics, but it was especially difficult in Islamic Central Asia. However, it is noted that unlike the Bukhara and Khiva khanates, Muslim women of Russian Turkestan gained support from the administration and the police, which helped them resist the traditional provisions of customary law and Sharia. Imperial civil law was considered the norm according to which women could turn to the authorities for protecting their rights. The author also reveals the influence of the new “Regulations on the Administration of the Turkestan Territory” adopted in 1886, which worsened the living conditions of women and left them with the opportunity to protect their rights only through the adoption of Christianity (Orthodoxy). Nevertheless, based on various sources, the article shows that the position of women in the region under Russian rule had significantly improved compared to the preimperial period.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):272-285
pages 272-285 views

The Germans of St. Petersburg from the 1860s to 1914: Number, Distribution, and Economic Activities

Shaidurov V.N., Osipov N.A.

Abstract

The authors examine the situation of the German community in St. Petersburg in the second half of the XIX - early XX century. The research is based on the published materials of the urban population censuses of 1869 and 1900 and the First General Census of Population of 1897 in St. Petersburg, as well as medical descriptions of commercial and industrial establishments of the capital. These office documents including petitions from artisans and other persons, correspondence between the bodies of city management and central departments, contracts for the execution of orders found in the central and regional archives of the Russian Federation. The research shows that in the 1860s and 1900s, the bulk of German citizens moved from the central parts of St. Petersburg to newly built areas of the city largely due to the economic reasons. In the industrial parts of the city, German women made up the majority of ethnic Germans. In the late XIX - early XX century, the German population continued to play an important role in the system of interethnic division of labor of city. They occupied dominant positions in education, medicine, and credit institutions. In addition, despite the rapid development of large-scale industry, artisans still played an important role in the urban economy and the Germans continue to make a significant impact.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):286-298
pages 286-298 views

Interaction of Central and Local Authorities with the Kazakh Population of the Steppe Region in the Field of Land Use in Late ХIХ - Early ХХ Century

Lysenko Y.A., Omurova Z.O., Gundova O.E.

Abstract

The authors analyze the interaction between the central and regional authorities and the Kazakhs of the Steppe Region at the turn of the XX century on land use issues. The study reveals the problems in this area caused by the mass migration of the peasant population to the region and the process of land seizure by the state to create resettlement sites. The aim is to reconstruct the regulatory framework for appeals of the Kazakh population to the government bodies on the issues of land use, and the procedure for their consideration and decision-making mechanisms. The source base for the article is: the Kazakhs’ petitions and requests, as well as other office materials - interdepartmental correspondence, minutes of meetings, reports, resolutions and decrees - of the Governing Senate, as well as the Department of Agriculture and State Property of the Ministry of the Interior, the Ministry of Justice, and the regional governments of the Akmola and Semipalatinsk regions of the Governor-Generalship of the Steppes as found in the Russian State Historical Archive. The sources used has allow the authors to develop the stated goal of the article, and they have been able show that the main form of interaction between the central and regional authorities and the Kazakhs of the Steppe Region on land use issues were the Kazakhs’ petitions and requests. If a decision concerning their appeals was negative, the Kazakhs had the right to turn to the Governing Senate, the Ministry of the Interior, and the State Duma. In such cases, there were official proceedings lasting up to several years. The decisions on them were necessarily announced to the plaintiffs. The authors concluded that the Kazakhs actively used the tools provided by legislation to resolve land use issues. Nevertheless, it is revealed that in most cases, the central authorities confirmed the legitimacy of regional administration decisions on the seizure of land plots. However, the significant number of petitions and requests testifies to the fact that in the matters of defending their economic interests the Kazakhs were given equal opportunities with other subjects of the Russian Empire.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):299-309
pages 299-309 views

Some Issues of the RSFSR Federal Construction in the 1920s

Amanzholova D.A.

Abstract

The author considers the problems of the relationship between the multi-level authorities and management, and the center and national autonomies in the RSFSR, as among the most complex hierarchical arrangement of the USSR. The author reveals the place and significance of the so-called private meeting of national workers (November 1926) and the discussion of its results on the ground in solving the key issues of nation-building and Soviet modernization of the multi-ethnic country. The research is based on the published materials, as well as archival documents related to the meeting in Moscow in November 1926 and its discussion in: the autonomies (the Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History (F. 17 - the Central Committee of the Russian communist party of the Bolsheviks - All-Union Communist Party, F. 78 - M.I. Kalinin), the Archive of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan (F. 141 - the Kazakh Regional Committee of the Russian communist party of the Bolsheviks - All-Union Communist Party), and the State Archive of the Russian Federation (F. 3316 - Central Executive Committee of the USSR). The author concludes that the federal construction was accompanied by intense search for balance between state bodies, and the discussions between representatives of the center and autonomies concerned: the determination of the status of the autonomies, the adjustment of the management mechanism, the distribution of powers and interaction of all-Russian and autonomist structures, the role of the center and ethno-political elites in the implementation of the tasks of ethno-national policy, and the strengthening of statehood.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):310-321
pages 310-321 views

Why the Roma National District Was Not Founded in the RSFSR and What it Could Have Been Like

Kamenskikh M.S.

Abstract

The author analyzes the activities of Soviet policy towards the Roma population with a focus on state involvement in agricultural cooperation and the creation of Roma collective farms in the Volga region in the 1930s. During that period, even small national groups gained autonomy in the form of republics, districts, and even regions. Therefore, the question of why territorial autonomy for Roma was not founded in the USSR seems quite currently relevant. Meanwhile, in 1936-1937 in the RSFSR, as part of the policy of settling the Roma, the project for creating the Roma national district in the Kuibyshev region was seriously discussed and considered. The circumstances and reasons for the failure to implement the project of creating the Roma national district in the Volga region are clarified across the article. The basis for the research is the archival materials of the fund of the All-Union Resettlement Committee of the Russian State Academy of Economics (fund 5675) introduced by the author into scientific use for the first time. The sources allow revealing the circumstances of the discussion and preparatory work on the creation of the Roma national district. The funds contain significant information and reports with a detailed description of the Roma collective farms, including those containing ethnographic material. The author concludes that the project of creating the Roma national district was of strategic importance for the Soviet leadership and the authorities made great efforts to implement it. By early 1937, all the necessary conditions for the establishment of the district had been created. However, the reluctance of the lower power structures to host the Roma population, the outbreak of large repressions, the abolition of the All-Union Resettlement Committee, and the change of trends in the national policy prevented the implementation of the project.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):322-334
pages 322-334 views

HISTORICAL URBANISTICS

From Imperial Capitals to Megacities: St. Petersburg and Moscow in the Second Half of the XIX Century

Shevyrev A.P.

Abstract

The author examines the evolution of St. Petersburg and Moscow, the Russian capitals, into megacities under the influence of industrialization in the second half of the XIX century. The urbanization processes in these cities and the challenges they faced are analyzed within the body of the text. The source base is the materials of the statistics, journalism, travel guides and research papers on historical urbanism of the period. The article shows that in the second half of the XIX century, under the conditions of rapid industrialization, both capitals became the largest industrial and commercial centers of the Russian Empire, a situation which contributed to the rapid growth of the population of these cities and their urbanization. Both capitals faced urgent problems of large cities: housing, water and air pollution, which caused high morbidity and mortality among the population. At the same time, new urban trends emerged, in particular, zoning of urban space, and, both cities had al achieved considerable achievements in the modernization of their infrastructure: horse-drawn railways were constructed, gas, kerosene and even electric lighting was installed, and water was purified. Thus, in the second half of the XIX century, both Russian capitals went through the same purgatory that European capitals had gone through several decades earlier. While neither Moscow nor even St. Petersburg during this period had yet become attractive enough for tourists wishing to see the sights of a modern metropolis, nevertheless, both capitals grew to become appealing megacities in the early XX century.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):335-345
pages 335-345 views

First Domestic Asphalt Paving Companies

Morozan V.V.

Abstract

In their article, author considers the historical experience of introducing new methods of road paving into the practice of road maintenance in St. Petersburg. Obviously, this example is of interest to modern city authorities. The purpose of the study is to determine the degree of development of the asphalt production industry and methods of attracting firms and companies to manufacture road surfaces in the urban environment of the Russian Empire. The topic has practically not been considered by Russian and foreign historians. The source base for the article is documentary materials from St. Petersburg archives. The information on the activities of enterprises producing asphalt and road works was taken from the funds of the St. Petersburg office of the State Bank of Russia, the city government of the capital, and the boards of asphalt enterprises. Modern methods of paving Russian city streets have had relatively brief history. They began to be widely introduced into the urban environment in large economic centers of pre-revolutionary Russia only in the last quarter of the XIX century. The first such pavements appeared in St. Petersburg, Moscow, Warsaw, Odessa and other Russian cities during that period. It should be noted that due to various reasons the asphalt production industry in the Russian Empire was poorly developed, by the First World War, it was in deep crisis. Subsequent events in Russia definitively scaled back the asphalt production in the country, which was revived only by the 1930s.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):346-357
pages 346-357 views

ARTICLES

The Great Eastern Question: Development of the Pro-Eurasian Worldview of Ismail Gasprinsky at the Beginning of the ХХ Сentury

Seliverstov S.V.

Abstract

The article reconstructs the views of the Russian Turkic-Muslim figure and educator Ismail Gasprinsky in 1908-1914. It examines the direction in which I. Gasprinsky's views evolved in relation to a conceptual Russian-Eastern Agreement due to a continued aggravation of domestic and regional international problems at the beginning of the twentieth century. Based on the journalism of the Terdzhiman newspaper, it is revealed that Gasprinsky continued to expand his views to the “Great Eastern Question” during the period and develop the concept of the Eastern Agreement, taking into account the central position of both Russia and Turkey, as well as the Slavs and Turkic peoples in general. However, by the beginning of the twentieth century, the Eastern Question had transformed from Slavic-Turkish issue to Slavic-German one. According to Gasprinsky, the solution was to create a Slavic-Turkic “dam” against the “wave” of Germanism. At the new stage, he did not retreat from his central ideas and continued to remain a supporter of Russian-Muslim cooperation. The author concludes that Gasprinsky's worldview was largely pro-Eurasian in content, and the concept of an eastern agreement had developed by the beginning of the ХХ century to the level of a possible diplomatic breakthrough and had become a significant contribution to early Eurasian social thought and to the intellectual development of Russia and the Turkic world as a whole.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):358-369
pages 358-369 views

Problems of Oil Transportation in the Ural-Emba Region: The Government Debate in 1920-1921

Eshchenko Y.G.

Abstract

The author analyzes the problems of organizing oil transportation from the Ural-Emba region based on the materials of the discussion that took place in the Soviet government in 1920-1921 regarding the feasibility of constructing new transport communications - a railway and an oil pipeline - from oil fields to the central industrial regions of the Russian Empire. Based on the sources such as a complex of the published legislative documents and archival materials, some of which are being introduced into scientific use for the first time, the authors considers: the measures taken by the country's leadership to resolve the fuel crisis of 1918-1919, the reasons for the decision to build the Aleksandrov Gai - Emba railway and the Emba - Saratov oil pipeline, the main arguments of the discussion participants about the need to continue the construction, and the difficulties that arose during the construction process, difficulties which ultimately led to the closure of the project. The author comes to the conclusion that among the reasons for freezing the construction of Emba facilities were the Soviet government’s lack of experience in implementing large economic projects in military conditions, insufficient qualifications of managers and specialists of relevant departments, and lack of a built system of construction preparation and planning.

RUDN Journal of Russian History. 2024;23(3):370-381
pages 370-381 views

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies