Vol 16, No 3 (2024): Legal and social life of ancient societies
- Year: 2024
- Articles: 12
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/world-history/issue/view/1802
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2312-8127-2024-16-3
Full Issue
LAW AND POWER IN ANCIENT ROME
Locatio in Roman agrimensura
Abstract
The relevance of this study is due to the lack of works in Russian historiography that would examine in detail the phenomenon of locatio as an act of creating a possession. Using a comprehensive method of historical research, the author comprehensively studies both the legal component of the mentioned phenomenon and its practical component: we are talking about arcifinius as a technical expression of locus. The author’s goal is to, having comprehensively studied the procedure of simple locatio, give a legal assessment of the phenomenon itself, as well as determine its place in the system of Roman agrimensura and in Roman land law. The work uses the works of outstanding Roman agrimensors, such as Hyginus the Elder and Agennius Urbicus (Corpus Agrimensorum Romanorum), as well as extensive historiography, both domestic and foreign. As a result of the undertaken research, the author comes to the following conclusions: firstly, locus and arcifinius in the archaic period of Roman history symbolized the category ager publicus; secondly, the possession that arose in the public field as a result of locatio was secured by the ancient law of ius Quiritium and retained its significance until the era of the Empire; thirdly, during the Empire, land provided to citizens as possessions on a lease basis began to be allocated in a similar way. Thus, the ancient locatio retains its significance throughout the history of the Roman state.
Once again about the category of «luxury» in the economy and law of ancient Rome
Abstract
In recent decades, Roman sumptuary laws have been actively studied in classical studies, which are traditionally associated with the theory of “decline of morals”: according to this theory, the crisis of the Roman state was caused by the process of decomposition of traditional norms and values under the influence of foreign morals, luxury and wealth. In this context, the relevance of the undertaken research is obvious. The author sets himself the goal of studying in detail the internally contradictory essence of such a phenomenon as Roman sumptuary laws. In particular, he draws attention to the conventional nature of the term “sumptuary laws” used in Russian-language literature, which does not accurately convey the meaning of the Latin phrase leges sumptuariae. The study draws on a range of Latin texts and other sources, as well as an extensive research literature. As a result, the author comes to the following conclusions: firstly, if the word luxus was associated with phenomena introduced into the life of the Roman civil community by the Hellenistic civilization and resulting from the military activity of Rome in the south of Italy and beyond, then the term sumptus was associated with the original Roman ideas about moderation and frugality, which must be considered, first of all, in the context of the life of the familia and its economic activities. Secondly, if the term luxus reflected the concept of luxury as such, then the use of the word sumptus was associated with housekeeping in general and with the concept of expenses in particular.
Expressiveness of numbers in “The Achievements of the Divine Augustus”
Abstract
The article examines the nature and significance of the various numerical and statistical data used in the “Achievements of the Divine Augustus” ( Res gestae Divi Augusti ), and seeks to demonstrate what reality and how they describe, what impression they are designed to produce. It is concluded that the numerical data of the “Achievements” contain important, in many cases unique and quite reliable information, showing the grandeur of the princeps’ achievements. There is the conscious focus on the exceptionally abundant use of numerals, which both in dating formulas and in the actual statistical information give the narrative a businesslike, concrete character, allowing to avoid excessive and unfounded pathos, but at the same time, with irresistible obviousness, show the unconditional superiority of Augustus as a benefactor, military and state leader in comparison with both contemporaries and predecessors, turning an autobiographical account into a political testament addressed to the “City and the World” and establishing the key ideological parameters of an ideal ruler.
The institution of hostages in Roman political practice at the end of the Republic and at the beginning of the Empire
Abstract
The relevance of the research topic is due to the fact that even at the end of the first quarter of the 21st century the term “hostages”, meaning persons unlawfully held to achieve some goal (military, political, economic, etc.), has by no means disappeared from the political vocabulary. Of course, between the political institution of hostages, which became widespread in the ancient world and was an important element of the diplomatic practice of that epoch, and hostages, who in modern times were repeatedly captured and forcibly held by terrorists and extremists of all stripes, who did not stop at killing or causing grave harm to the health of the captured people, a huge distance has passed. The purpose of this study is to identify the features of the institution of hostage in antiquity using the example of ancient Rome. Having analyzed the sources, the author came to the conclusion: if during the epoch of the Republic there were very few episodes associated with the stay of royal hostages in Rome and there was no wellthought-out policy in this direction in principle, then with the establishment of the Empire its founder, Augustus, began to pursue a political course aimed at creating an entire system of client states dependent on Rome, led by monarchs who, living in Rome as hostages, were raised, educated and subjected to Romanization in order to subsequently serve the emperor as loyal vassals and conductors of Roman influence in the periphery. For a number of reasons, this policy was not successful, and Augustus’ successors gradually abandoned it.
THE ECONOMICS OF ANTIQUITY
The Role of the Archon in the Organizing the Lease of Sacred Lands in Attica in the Second Half of the V-IV Centuries B.C.
Abstract
The purpose of the study is to present the functions of the archon in the process of organizing the lease of sacred lands (temenos) in Attica in the second half of the V - IV centuries B.C. basing on the study of epigraphic material. The study of this problem seems relevant as far as there are presented works in historiography concerning the powers of this official in the socio-political life of Athens, but is not considered the issue of the impact of his activities on the polis’ economy. Having analyzed the content of the temenos lease agreements, the author characterized the functions of the archon in determining the composition of the participants as well as the terms of transaction. Basing on the text of the inscriptions, it was carried out a comparison of the powers of the archons in the organization of the lease of sacred lands in Attica in the second half of the 5th century B.C. and in the 4th century B.C. Finally, the author comes to the following conclusions. Firstly, the cancellation of lease agreements of sacred lands in Attica was not carried out without the archon’s verdict. Secondly, a comparative analysis of the content of the inscriptions of the second half of the fifth and fourth centuries B.C. gives an idea that through the time the role of the archon in the lease of temenos becomes less significant. It apparently can be explained by the increasing role of officials of individual collectives (for example, demarchs, phratryarchs or epimeletes).
Domitian and the Roman economy: some notes
Abstract
A comprehensive assessment of the state of the Roman economy during the reign of Emperor Domitian is difficult due to the unsatisfactory state of the sources, therefore it is necessary to proceed from the available information. In the field of finance, it allows us to conclude that the main source of state revenues were taxes, the receipt of which was under the strict control of the emperor. The tax policy of the last Flavius proved to be effective and ensured the balance of the State budget, despite the extraordinary expenses caused by wars and natural disasters. In the agricultural sector, the emperor secured his popularity among the Italian population by securing ownership of the “segments” that remained undivided after the withdrawal of the colonies to their actual owners. Domitian’s attempt to ensure an increase in grain production in Italy and the provinces by reducing urban plantations was rather advisory in nature and did not lead to significant results. In the capital of the Roman Empire, Domitian’s construction program, to which he attached great political importance, was successfully completed. Assessing the actions of the last Flavius in the field of economics, it should be concluded that he continued the economic policy of Vespasian and Titus, leaving his successors the Roman power in a state that ensured the last flourishing of ancient civilization.
Financial Policy of the Roman Governor towards Provincial Communities during Period of the Principate
Abstract
The area of responsibility of the governor of the province was to perform both commanding, judicial and fiscal duties. The latter had to replenish the treasury with tax revenues from the provinces. The governors needed funds to maintain the military troops accommodated in the province. Besides that, at least by the beginning of the 2nd century ensuring the financial stability of the provincial communities themselves became an important area. It was controlled by the governor. Tendance about the welfare of provincial cities is reflected, in particular, in the correspondence of Pliny the Younger with Trajan, the speeches of Dion Chrysostom as well as epigraphic documents of a legal nature. This and a number of other sources reflect various ways to maintain the financial well-being of communities by reducing the local taxes, lump-sum contributions and various unproductive expenses. In this regard, the Antonins’ is marked by a turn in the financial strategy of the Roman state towards the “humanization” of the provincial policy. Monitoring of city finances was an aspect that required the constant attention to the state of income and expenditure of provincial communities. At the same time, the viceroy was not limited to the personnel resources of his staff but tried to involve the local aristocracy, endowing its representatives with control and judicial powers, acting, however, in the context of the customs and practices evolved in each individual community.
THE FOREIGN POLICY
The treatise by Constantine Porphyrogenitus ‘De Administrando Imperio’ on the Chersonesos participation in the 3rd-4th centuries’ wars: military tactical aspect
Abstract
The article is devoted to the study of the military-tactical aspect of four wars late 3rd - first half of the 4th century. During this wars the Chersonesos polis participated on the side of Rome. Information about them is presented in chapter 53 of the of the Byzantine emperor Constantine Porphyrogenitus tractate «De Administrando Imperio». This passage is an organic part of the treatise and was placed in it deliberately, as an example of Chersonesites valor, cunning and loyalty to Rome, which was useful for the addressee of the narrative - the young Emperor Romanus II. It has been established, that the use of a mobile detachment of carts armed with light throwing artillery for ambush operations during the « Battle at Bosporus » in 291 was an innovation in military affairs, which attracted the attention of Constantine Porphyrogenitus. Other aspects of this battle correlate with the instructions of the treatise «De re militari» by Vegetius Flavius. The victorious participation of the Chersonesos troops in the next two battles - on the Danube and «At Kafa» - gave Chersonesos confidence in their abilities and made it possible for the first time in history to expand the possessions of their state to the borders of the Kerch Peninsula. The duel between the Archon of Chersonesos, Pharnaces, and the Bosporan king, which decided the outcome of the confrontation in the fourth war, is not fiction and has numerous analogies in both previous Greco-Roman and subsequent Byzantine history.
SPORTS IN ANCIENT GREECE
Greek pentathletes: the path to victory
Abstract
The purpose of the study is to find out how the Greek pentathlon was organized at the Panhellenic Games as well as what was the sequence of competitions in it, whether the rules of its organization differed at the Panhellenic and the local Games, how the judges determined the winner, and which path the pentathlete had to go to victory. Basing on the written sources and epigraphic data, the author demonstrates that the basic principle of the pentathlon organizing was developed at the Olympic Games, but deviations from it were possible at the local Games. The sequence of pentathlon competitions and the determination of the absolute winner is one of the most difficult tasks in the scientific literature but it is directly related to the question of which competitions the athlete should have won on the path to victory. Statistical analysis of data on the athletes’ victories in the pentathlon as well as on the pentathletes’ victories in special disciplines allow the author to assume that pentathletes more often won due to competitions in running rather than in wrestling, and that a track and field athlete had good chances of winning rather than a martial artist.
THE HISTORY OF PRE-COLUMBIAN AMERICA
Early State Formation in the Maya Lowlands in the Preclassic (1000 BCE - 150 CE)
Abstract
The emergence of the state was one of the crucial moments in human history. Ancient Mesoamerica was one of two main areas of the state formation in the New World in pre-Columbian epoch. Archaeological projects in the Maya Lowlands during last decades shed new light on the early stages of the Maya politogenesis in the Preclassic period. Recent trend in the study of Mesoamerican complex polities consists in defining them just as ‘kingdoms’ without specifying whether they were chiefdoms or states. At the same time some scholars suggest that urbanism and statehood could be identified already in the Middle Preclassic (1000-350 BCE). In the present paper basic traits of the evolution of the Preclassic Maya society will be outlined based on different types of data (settlement patterns, economy, social stratification, ritual and ideology). Archaeological data demonstrate that in beginning of the Late Preclassic (350/300 BCE - 200 CE) Maya societies transformed from chiefdoms with three-tiered settlement system, monumental architecture, and incipient urbanization to more complex polities characterized by four-tiered settlement hierarchies, early urban settlements with massive monumental architecture, and complex intensive agriculture. Analysis of the retrospective Maya hieroglyphic inscriptions of the Classic period (200-900 CE) shows that in the Maya historical memory this time was remembered as the period of the foundation of the most ancient dynasties and polities, and the epoch of the establishing of the political order. The beginning of the process of the formation of the Maya early states could be dated between 350 and 200 BCE.
Uaxactun Emblem Glyph: the evolution of the Classic Maya royal title
Abstract
The research of Uaxactun monuments (Peten, Guatemala) in 2000s made it possible to reconstruct the dynastic history of this Classic Maya political center (300-900). The study of inscriptions is complicated by the poor preservation of stone monuments, therefore, digital methods currently help in the analysis of monuments (photogrammetry, 3D modeling). This allowed us to determine also the royal title of the local dynasty and the main stages of its evolution. The analysis of the inscriptions identified about 20 examples of Uaxactun Emblem Glyph (a marker of the independent Maya polity) and related toponyms. It can be concluded that in the Early Classic after 300 AD Uaxactun lords used the traditional Emblem Glyph “king of Kʹanwitz”, which toponym Kʹanwitz (“Flat hill”) possibly was associated with the Group A of the site - the early ceremonial center located on a top of the high hill. Then, after 378, the usual Emblem Glyph disappears from inscriptions, what was caused by the Uaxactun subordination to the Teotihuacan power. Then until the early 6th cent. the dynasty began to be associated with another toponym Kʹan…kok (complete reading is unclear), which meant the neighboring architectural complex - Group B. After the Uaxactun hiatus period in the 6th-7th cent. the dynasty was revived again around 700 and its kings used the new title “king of Kʹan…kok”, adding the royal title ʹajaw to the Early Classic toponym. Finally at the last stage of the city’s history after 800, during the collapse of the Classic Maya political system, the kings of Uaxactun added the title kʹuhul (“sacred”) to their Emblem Glyph, equating themselves with the most authoritative dynasties of the Classic epoch.
Palenque royal lists of the 7th-8th centuries
Abstract
Since the middle of the 5th century AD, the territory of the archaeological site of Palenque (Chiapas, Mexico) was the capital of the Baakal state, the city of Lakamha’. A large number of monumental texts have been discovered here, which are of particular interest for the study of the organization and functioning of the royal court of the ancient Maya. The main objective of this work was to examine in detail the royal lists preserved in the monumental texts in order to reconstruct the kinship ties between the Palenque rulers and to reveal the peculiarities of the local political system. One of the main features to be considered about these written sources is a retrospective character, which in theory could give the rulers who created them wide opportunities for manipulation. The lack of detailed information about the rulers of the 5th-7th centuries, which is mainly limited to the dates of accession and death, is no less difficult. Although in the written tradition the royal dynasty is presented as a continuous one, the analysis of the texts reveals several lineages. Study also shows certain peculiarities of the system of power transmission in Baakal. In general, ancient Maya used patrilineal tradition, but the history of Palenque records cases different from this pattern. The throne there was once occupied by a woman, other cases show successive rule of several siblings. These data reveal the flexibility of the political system of the ancient Maya.