Dostoevsky - Strakhov - Tolstoy: Toward to the Story of One Conflict

Cover Page

Cite item


The well-known epistolary conflict between Fyodor Dostoevsky and Nikolai Strakhov over the latter's slander of the great Russian writer's terrible sins is considered in the article from the point of view a philosophical anthropology and relations not two but between three participants of this story: Dostoyevsky, Strakhov and Tolstoy. This conflict is presented through anthropological, existential, and class prisms of description, based on a reconstruction of Strakhov's concept of man as a controversial, dual, and undefined being reflected in Dostoevsky's work. A direct relation between the definition of the dual nature of man in the works of Strakhov and Dostoevsky and interpersonal conflicts within "boundary forms of literature" is substantiated. Special attention is paid to the class of seminarians, the object of Dostoevsky's targeted criticism. He saw their worst characteristics in Strakhov personality. Tolstoy plays the role of an arbiter in this controversy, assessing the situation both in terms of literary, existential and religious thought. In the course of his examination of this conflict, his unexpected closeness to Dostoevsky was discovered in regard to assessment of Strakhov. The point of their coincidence was the "pink Christianity" of the writers, who justify man in a quite similar manner, in terms of their religious consciousness.

About the authors

Svetlana M. Klimova

HSE University

Author for correspondence.

Doctor of Philosophy, Professor, the Faculty of Humanities, School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies

20, Myasnitskaya St., Moscow, 101000, Russian Federation


  1. Tolstoy L.N. & Strakhov N.N. Complete Collection of Corre-spondence in Two Volumes. Moscow; Ottava; 2003. Vol. 2. (In Russian).
  2. Tunimanov VA. Dostoevsky, Strakhov, Tolstoy: (Labyrinth of Clutches). Russkaya Literatura. 2006;(3): 38—96. (In Russian).
  3. Chyzhevsky DI. Hegel in Russia. St Peterburg; 2007. (In Russian).
  4. Orwin D. Strakhov's World as a Whole: A Missing Link between Dostoevsky and Tolstoy. Tolstoy. Novyy vek: zhurn. razmyshleniy: o Tolstom, o mire, o sebe. Yasnaya Polyana. 2006;(2): 197—221. (In Russian).
  5. Dolinin AS. Dostoevsky & Strakhov. In: Dolinin AS. Dostoevsky and others: articles and research about Russian сlassical literature. Leningrad; 1989. P. 234—270.
  6. Chyzhevsky DI. Ivan Karamasov's Devil and N.N. Strakhov. Voprosy filosofii. 2014;(5): 110—115. (In Russian).
  7. Toichkina AV. "I kak pishet kritik Strakhov…" (Tema spiritizma v publitsistike Dostoevskogo, N.N. Strakhova i v romane "Brat'ya Karamazovy"). In: Dostoevskiy i zhurnalizm. VN Zakharov, KA Stepanyan, BN Tikhomirov, editors. St Petersburg: Dmitriy Bulanin; 2013. P. 299—315. (In Russian).
  8. Snetova NV. N.N. Strakhov's philosophy: (an experience of intellectual biography). Perm: Perm University, 2010. 250 s. (In Russian).
  9. Brosova NZ. Strakhov kak istorik filosofii. Credo. 2000;(1): 23—32. (In Russian).
  10. Tolstoy L.N. & Strakhov N.N. Complete Collection of Corre-spondence in Two Volumes. Moscow; Ottava; 2003. Vol. 1. (In Russian).
  11. Dostoevsky FM. Complete collected works in 30 vols (1972—1990). Vol. 29. Book 1. Leningrad: Nauka; 1986. P. 14—22. (In Russian).
  12. Koni A.F. Iz vospominaniy "Lev Nikolaevich Tolstoy" 1887. In: Remizov VB. Tolstoy i Dostoevskiy. Brat'ya po sovesti. Moscow: RG-Press; 2019. (In Russian).
  13. Shestidesyatye gody. NK Piksanov, ON Tsekhnovitser, editors. Moscow; 1940. (In Russian).
  14. M. Shcherbakova, ed. Aksakov I.S. — Strakhov N.N: Perepiska. Ottawa; 2007. (In Russian).
  15. Tarasova NA. "A Writer's Diary" by F. Dostoevsky (1876—1877): a review of the text. Moscow: Kvadriga; MBA, 2011. (In Russian).
  16. Dostoevsky FM. Complete collected works in 30 vols (1972—1990). Vol. 24. Leningrad: Nauka; 1982. S. 239—240. (In Russian).
  17. Kirpotin VYa. Mir Dostoevskogo. Stat'i. Issledovaniya. Second edition. Moscow: Sovetskiy pisatel'; 1983. (In Russian).
  18. Paperno I. Leo Tolstoy's Correspondence with Nikolai Strakhov: The Dialogue on Faith». In: Anniversary Essays on Tolstoy. Ed. by Donna Tussing Orwin. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010. P. 96—119.
  19. Rozenblyum LM. "…Ikh nado oblichat' i obnaruzhivat' neustanno". In: Neizdannyy Dostoevskiy. Zapisnye knizhki i tetradi 1860—1881. Moscow; 1971. P. 16—23. (In Russian).
  20. Kibalnik SA. Solving the Riddle of a Writer's Defamation: Why Did Nikolay Strakhov Slander Fyodor Dostoevsky? Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filologiya. 2018;(55): 191—211. (In Russian).

Copyright (c) 2021 Klimova S.M.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies