Ecosystem in Modern Law: Theoretical Approaches and Legal Regulation

Cover Page

Cite item

Abstract

Based on the analysis of how the concept of “ecosystem” has emerged and evolved in science from natural ecosystems to digital ecosystems, this article identifies ambiguities in the interpretation of the concept in contemporary scholarship and current legislation and establishes the relationship between a digital platform and an ecosystem. An ecosystem, understood as a type of socio-economic system, is considered a form of partnership, a set or complex of services, a level of development of digital interaction, a business model, and an environment for innovation and digital development. The development of ecosystem theory in modern science makes it possible to regard the ecosystem approach as an independent method of scientific analysis. The article systematizes the features and structure of ecosystems, their levels and types, and the main problems and priorities for legal regulation. The interdisciplinary character of the ecosystem concept dictated the use of interdisciplinary methods; the study employs historical and comparative analysis, system analysis, classification, and formalization. In summary, an ecosystem, including a digital ecosystem, may be regarded in legal scholarship as an intersectoral legal institution encompassing norms from information, administrative, financial, banking, civil, and other branches of law that collectively regulate interactions within and between ecosystems, ensure sustainable economic development, freedom of competition, and the safety of participants. The paper draws attention to a transformation of the fundamental principles that underlie the understanding of socio-economic ecosystems in the context of digitalization, particularly in the justification of the mediation mechanism in digital interactions within the ecosystems. The transnational character of modern ecosystems is also substantiated. The article argues that treating the ecosystem as a single, autonomous object of legal regulation is inappropriate; instead, regulatory attention should focus on three aspects of its functioning: corporate, competition-related, and consumer-related. Finally, the paper substantiates the need for preventive state intervention that combines information-security measures with policies aimed at stimulating ecosystem development.

Full Text

Introduction

Digital technologies have fundamentally transformed our lives and continue to do so. The forms and speed of creating, collecting, storing, and transmitting information, as well as consumer demands and preferences for goods and services, are changing, along with the nature of connections among all participants in economic and other social interactions. Today, such interactions are almost unimaginable without digital platforms and ecosystems, which are increasingly becoming part of our everyday life, making it simpler and more convenient, while also requiring fundamentally new regulatory and dispute-resolution tools.

The ecosystem concept now permeates the lives of virtually all consumers. We carry out hundreds and thousands of transactions each day, satisfying ordinary and extraordinary needs, selecting information, goods, and services, conducting financial transactions, and communicating with other citizens, organizations, and the state. A significant share of these activities is carried out through ecosystems, the best known of which are domestic ecosystems such as Sber and Yandex, each with more than 100 million users, as well as VK (90 million), MTS (79.7 million), and MegaFon (over 74 million). Russian ecosystems are still in their infancy and do not yet make a significant contribution to macroeconomic indicators. Moreover, the average net profit of domestic players is almost 60 times lower than that of global leaders[1]. In addition to commercial ecosystems, Russia has also established and successfully operated a state digital ecosystem, Gosuslugi (State Services).

In legislation, the use of the concept of “ecosystem” remains cautious, ambiguous, contradictory, and inconsistent. The legal framework reveals a certain mixture of horizontal and vertical constructs, as well as of spatial (ecological-geographical) and informational (digital) approaches with legislators often using, sometimes even within a single legal act, such categories as “unique ecosystem of Lake Baikal,” “digital ecosystem of the Northern Sea Route,” and “digital ecosystem of the One-Stop Shop,” among others[2].

The relevance of this research topic has been further increased by the submission of a draft federal law, “On the Platform Economy in the Russian Federation,” by the Russian Ministry of Economic Development to the Government of the Russian Federation in February 2025. The draft law is intended to create a legal framework for the platform economy and regulate relations between platform operators, their partners, and users[3].

Although the authors of the draft law have included a specific category of platforms, namely intermediary digital platforms, within its scope, the draft is still viewed as an important step toward regulating the creation and operation of digital platforms and ecosystems.

This article seeks to define the concept of an ecosystem in legal science and legislation, identify the characteristics and structure of ecosystems, their levels and types, and determine current issues and priorities in the legal regulation of ecosystem functioning.

The Concept of an Ecosystem in Modern Legal Science

The Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary offers the following definition of an ecosystem: an ecosystem (from the Greek oikos, meaning dwelling or place of residence, and system) is a unified natural complex formed by living organisms and their environment, in which living and non-living components are interconnected through the exchange of substances and energy. The concept of an ecosystem applies to natural objects of varying complexity and size. The terms “ecosystem” and “biogeocenosis” are often used synonymously[4], although some authors distinguish between them (Grigor'eva & Grigor'ev, 2012).

 Originally, the ecosystem category in science was associated with ecology. This ecological approach was later extended to social interaction and development. Scientists compare ecosystem functioning to the processes that constitute physiological functioning in an organism, viewing these functions as the basis for the sustainable provision of “goods” and “services” on which people depend (Christensen & Franklin, 1997:1–2).

A socio-economic ecosystem is understood as a localized complex of organizations, business processes, innovative projects, and infrastructure entities capable of long-term independent functioning through the circulation of resources, products, and systems (Kleiner, 2019:40). In essence, a socio-economic ecosystem is based on the creation, differentiation, and circulation of information (analogous to the circulation of matter and energy in natural ecosystems), which determines the nature of the services provided to consumers within the ecosystem. Ecosystems are a type of socio-economic system (Kleiner, 2018:6).

In Russia, ecosystems in the financial sector (banking and other sectors) are particularly illustrative. For example, the Bank of Russia's public consultation report defines an ecosystem (digital ecosystem) as a set of services, including platform solutions, offered by a single group of companies or by a company together with its partners, enabling users to access a wide range of products and services within a single, seamless, integrated process. An ecosystem can include closed and open platforms. The range of services offered by the ecosystem satisfies most of a client's daily needs or is built around one or more of their basic needs[5].

According to the Strategy for the Development of the Information Society in the Russian Federation for 2017–2030, national interests in the digital economy include, among other things, the formation of new markets based on information and communication technologies, securing leadership in these markets through the effective use of knowledge, and developing the Russian digital ecosystem. In this document, the latter is defined as a partnership among organizations that ensures interaction between their technological platforms, applied internet services, analytical systems, and the information systems of Russian state bodies, organizations, and citizens[6].

An ecosystem is understood as an intermediate level between the enterprise as the primary element of economic relations and the market, whether industry-wide or territorial, as a whole. In this sense, an ecosystem acts as a natural systemic environment for the enterprise, making it possible to shift attention from the market as a whole to the intermediate structure between the enterprise and the market (Kleiner, 2019:40).

The modern understanding of an ecosystem as a business model is also quite widespread. A digital ecosystem is positioned as a customer-centric business model that integrates two or more groups of products, services, and information, whether produced internally or by other market participants, in order to satisfy the ultimate needs of customers such as security, housing, and entertainment[7]. There are also other interpretations of the ecosystem as a whole and of its individual varieties. For example, modern scholars view the entrepreneurial ecosystem as a source of entrepreneurial opportunities, or a window of opportunity (Trabskaja & Mets, 2019).

In relation to the digital industry, an ecosystem is understood as an environment that provides conditions for the innovative development and distribution of digital services, digital products, applications, and devices within a specific sector of the digital economy (Akatkin et al., 2017:22).

Thus, the concept of an ecosystem in modern science is characterized by ambiguous interpretations. An ecosystem, as a type of socio-economic system, is currently positioned as a form of partnership, a set or complex of services, a level of digital interaction development, a business model, and an environment for innovative and digital development.

In our view, it is especially important to distinguish between the categories of “digital platform” and “ecosystem.” In this regard, several possible relationships between these categories can be identified.

First, some approaches combine these categories and treat them as synonymous. This identification is rather arbitrary, since scientists ultimately recognize that numerous services and platforms together form a distinct ecosystem (Gabov, 2022).

Second, some approaches distinguish between them on the basis of various quantitative and qualitative criteria. Platform models, meaning digital and technological platforms, and ecosystems are differentiated, though not always clearly or consistently. According to the glossary proposed in the Bank of Russia’s report, the concept of ecosystem is broader and includes both closed and open platforms[8].

It is generally accepted that both concepts originated in the offline world and later, with the development of digitalization, offline platforms and ecosystems, such as retail, logistics, and service centers in cities, airports, railway stations, shopping and entertainment centers, movie theaters, and similar entities, began to transform into digital ones.

The aforementioned draft law defines a digital platform as an information system and/or website on the Internet, and/or computer programs that provide technical, organizational, informational, and other capabilities for interaction among an unlimited number of people, including for the purposes of exchanging and disseminating information, selling goods, performing work, and providing services[9].

Today, a digital platform is also understood as a business model that enables consumers and suppliers to connect online in order to exchange products, services, and information, including in-house products, services, and information. A digital ecosystem, in turn, is understood as a customer-centric business model that integrates two or more groups of products, services, and information, that is, two or more digital platforms[10]. The understanding of an ecosystem as a “cluster of platforms” is quite common (Samsonova et al., 2022).

In some cases, the legislator approves a specific list of services and digital infrastructure implemented for the purpose of forming a particular ecosystem, for example, the ecosystem of digital transport corridors of the Eurasian Economic Union[11].

G.B. Kleiner believes that each ecosystem contains clusters, platforms, networks and incubators (Kleiner, 2018:11), while the platform component of ecosystems plays, rather, the role of a connecting link or a border strip between the ecosystem and the surrounding world (Kleiner, 2018:13).

Third, there are approaches according to which digital ecosystems represent the next stage in the development of digital platforms[12]. We believe that an ecosystem is more than the mere sum or cluster of two or more digital platforms. Such integration is deeper: it creates qualitatively new value in the interaction between the ecosystem and consumers, a value that undoubtedly constitutes a competitive advantage and has economic significance. A.V. Gabov rightly notes that an ecosystem enables its participants to pursue multiple interests, not only economic ones (Gabov, 2022). Typically, a core or “anchor” business gradually acquires additional services whose role, attractiveness, and profitability may grow and eventually dominate the structure of the ecosystem as a whole.

The development of platforms and ecosystems is certainly a contemporary trend. Customers increasingly choose ecosystems, while traditional business models are losing out in terms of convenience, choice, and cost. Leading global companies are building ecosystems in order to maintain long-term appeal and growth[13].

Thus, the concept of ecosystems, originating in natural science, has successfully entered socio-economic discourse. Today, one can speak not only of the evolution of the concept of ecosystems in social science, but also of the emergence and development of a specialized scientific approach, the ecosystem approach, in the study of modern social institutions, phenomena, and processes. This approach is especially important for the regulation of economic processes. It is no coincidence that the regulator, represented by the Bank of Russia, describes and forecasts the optimal structure of the Russian market in terms of the further successful development of platform and ecosystem solutions. The ecosystem approach and ecosystem solutions, which reduce costs through network management and essentially create new economic and other values, must be supported by legal and infrastructural measurers in the modern economy, especially since the accumulated regulatory experience in this area can only be partially applied to digital platforms and ecosystems. Digital platforms and ecosystems require fundamentally new legal regulation tools.

Ecosystem in Law and Legal Science

Given the natural-science origins of the concept of an “ecosystem,” its initial study in legal science has taken place within environmental law. Moreover, M.M. Brinchuk identifies the ecosystem approach as one of the principles of environmental law (Brinchuk, 2012:4).

Article 1 of the Federal Law “On Environmental Protection” No. 7-FZ dated 10.01.2002 introduces the concept of a natural ecological system[14]. In environmental legislation, ecosystems are regarded as a new generation of natural objects, and the sustainable functioning of natural ecological systems is treated by the legislator as one of the indicators (criteria) of a favorable environment (Brinchuk, 2012:6).

A digital ecosystem, unlike a natural ecological system, is consciously created by humans as a new generation of artificial ecological systems and is based on the exchange of digital information.

V.K. Andreev defines digital platforms and ecosystems as a specifically interconnected set of diverse services (Andreev, 2022). Experts rightly identify “two typical core sectors for ecosystems that are expanding into new branches: banks and internet companies”[15]. The foundation of ecosystems lies in digital services, virtual intermediation, and the provision of various services in a digital environment. When identifying different types of legal ecosystems, scholars argue that a realistic legal ecosystem on a digital platform, like most innovations, should be sought not so much in technology as in business models (Samsonova et al., 2022).

We believe that an ecosystem (digital ecosystem) can be considered in modern legal science as an interdisciplinary institution that encompasses norms from information law, administrative law, financial law, banking law, civil law, and other branches of law, collectively aimed at regulating interactions both within the internal structure of ecosystems and between them (different ecosystems), ensuring sustainable economic development, free competition, and the safety of participants in such interactions.

Ecosystems are essentially a new generation of units of economic analysis and at the same time objects of interdisciplinary legal regulation. We believe it is important to note a certain transformation of the fundamental principles underlying the understanding of ecosystems in the socio-economic sphere in the context of digitalization. In biology, the basic principle of an ecosystem, understood as a unified natural complex is the circulation of substances and energy that ensures the sustainable, environmentally oriented functioning and development of ecosystem in which all its elements thrive. A similar principle guided the early development of ecosystem theory as applied to business processes (entrepreneurial ecosystems, and others), where the bases of an ecosystem was the effective (non-conflict, mutually beneficial, optimal) interaction of multiple elements considered within a specific ecosystem at a specific level.

In our view, the concept of intermediation (aggregator, platform, service, “link,” etc.) underlies the understanding of ecosystems (digital ecosystem) in contemporary reality from legal, economic, digital, organizational, financial, and other perspectives. Scholars rightly note that digitalization has significantly transformed existing relationships through the emergence of the intermediary figure (Gabov, 2022). Thus, offline interactions did not require an intermediary, whereas digital interactions necessitated its creation and integration into a system of connections based on the exchange (circulation) of digital information. Modern economic and other social interactions in the digital environment can be optimal, effective, and maximally beneficial to all parties involved only when digital platforms function as intermediaries.

The diversity of such intermediaries (reflecting the variety of services they provide), their complementarity and interconnection, and their capacity for renewal and self-updating are conditions for the effective functioning of the ecosystem as a complex, a set, a registry of platforms. Services, including information services, act as a kind of primary element of exchange and interaction within and beyond the ecosystem, analogous to matter and energy in natural ecosystems. It is noteworthy that the concept of “ecosystem services” is also applied to natural ecosystems (Neang et al., 2019).

Ecosystem Characteristics and Structure

It appears that two key conditions, or foundations, for the development of a modern understanding of the ecosystem can be identified. First, there is the digitalization of social interaction, including digital platforms in the financial sector and e-commerce. Second, there is the changing behavior of customers, which involves not merely a shift in consumer preferences or demands, but a broader transformation of people's traditional way of life.

We believe that the state is present in any ecosystem, although it may be positioned and described differently, for example regulatory framework, regulator, state digital platform, legislation, government, or otherwise, and its degree of involvement in the ecosystem may vary at different stages of the ecosystem life cycle. Researchers also distinguish several spheres of state influence within the ecosystem, depending, for example, on the category of services provided to consumers by a particular public sector. In their view, the state also subsidizes the renewable resource industry in its country not only to maintain a minimum supply of this resource and support the main interchangeable renewable resource, but also to assist in the provision of general public services (Whitmore, 2007).

Given that the largest domestic ecosystems today are largely represented by the banking sector, modern scholars are actively studying banking ecosystems (Mikheeva, 2022) and include the following elements in their structure: 1) digital data; 2) information and telecommunications infrastructure; 3) information technology; and 4) the banking services market (Uzdenov, 2022).

In the regulatory framework, the structure of a specific ecosystem is limited to lists of digital platforms or digital service platforms, and infrastructure elements, such as (information and technical components, necessary for the full functioning of the ecosystem, for example, the digital ecosystem of the Northern Sea Route)[16].

When theoretically constructing the internal structure of a modern ecosystem, the question arises of how to position consumers of the services provided by digital platforms within the ecosystem. The ambiguity of their legal and, at the same time, “ecosystemic” status lies in the fact that, on the one hand, they act as consumers of ecosystem services and therefore participants in consumer relations, while on the other hand, they are regarded as participants in the ecosystem and as its constituent elements. Moreover, in the latter case, it is precisely their presence and their involvement, or connectedness, with the service provider that determine whether a digital service, or a set of digital services, is classified as an ecosystem. It is no coincidence that researchers of banking ecosystems note that it is the presence of a large client base that enables banks to form ecosystems and manage them effectively (Mikheeva, 2022).

Types and levels of ecosystems

Ecosystems can be formed on the basis of both territorial and mixed characteristics (Kleiner, 2018:6). In some cases, researchers combine sectoral and territorial approaches to the study of ecosystems, for example, when referring to the agroecosystem of a particular natural object (Neang et al., 2019).

We believe that the territorial criterion is currently of secondary importance for an ecosystem as a type of socio-economic, that is, non-natural and non-biological, system, given that the digital environment of modern ecosystem interactions to a certain extent erases state borders, and national jurisdictions. Leading scholars have drawn attention to the transboundary nature of digital platforms (Gabov, 2022). Nevertheless, both the legal framework and scientific research continue to preserve the spatial dimension of the ecosystem approach[17]. Scholars, in turn, substantiate the theoretical foundations of the entrepreneurial ecosystem, which is positioned as a tool for managing location-based change (O’Connor et al., 2018), and highlight the specifics of regional entrepreneurial ecosystems (Barinova, Zemtsov & Tsareva, 2018; Gamidullaeva & Agamagomedova, 2021).

The hierarchy of levels at which ecosystems are scientifically and normatively positioned today is quite extensive, ranging from the ecosystem of the personnel of an individual company18 to the global ecosystem (Whitmore, 2007: 23–46). In legal literature, the category “legal ecosystem as a whole” is also used (Samsonova et al., 2022).

It is also common to distinguish the ecosystem of the digital industry, understood as an environment that creates conditions for the innovative development and distribution of digital services, digital products, applications, and devices in a specific sector of the digital economy (Akatkin et al., 2017:22).

The classification of entrepreneurial ecosystems is quite broad. For example,  D. Moore identified many types of entrepreneurial ecosystems, including strong and weak, new and mature, living and dead, competitive and cooperative, even marginal entrepreneurial ecosystems (Moore, 1993:75–83).

Scientists consider mobile ecosystems to be one of the varieties of innovative and entrepreneurial systems (Doroshenko & Shelomentsev, 2017:218). The Bank of Russia's Report identifies ecosystems at the initial stage of their formation, or niche ecosystems, as well as monopoly ecosystems[19]. Educational ecosystems (Wu & Lin, 2019) and industrial ecosystems (Kleiner, 2018) are also distinguished. At the same time, the leading role of the financial sector in ecosystem formation is recognized as a national feature of Russia, and it is concluded that Russian technology companies are also moving in the ecosystem direction by expanding the range of their services, including by beginning to offer financial services to clients[20].

It is important to distinguish between two types of digital platforms and ecosystems, national and foreign, although these have yet to be clearly defined or distinguished by explicit criteria[21]. Given the need to ensure technological sovereignty for Russia, this distinction is particularly relevant.

Modern national standards use ecosystem types such as the “digital social insurance ecosystem”[22], and scholars are studying banking ecosystems (Mikheeva, 2022; Uzdenov, 2022), the digital ecosystem of copyright and related rights (Gots & Bliznets, 2021), and the information, or digital ecosystem of advocacy (Gavrilov & Volodina, 2019), among others. Moreover, in some cases, these do not concern traditional services for the provision of goods and services. Thus, by the information, or digital, ecosystem of the legal profession, scholars mean a unified digital environment for the legal profession, shaped by the digitization of internal corporate business processes and legal activities (Gavrilov, 2020). Another example of an ecosystem indirectly related to e-commerce is the digital ecosystem of copyright and related rights proposed by these scholars (Gots & Bliznets, 2021).

In some cases, scholars use the concept of an ecosystem, while in others they use the term digital ecosystem. Some authors also study one ecosystem within the framework of another, broader one (Gavrilov & Volodina, 2019). We believe that a modern ecosystem is always digital and always connected to the circulation of digital information and big data, which in itself is exceptionally valuable. To comprehensively address the challenges of digitalizing enterprises in Russia, the Efficiency.rf online resource has been launched as a digital ecosystem for enterprises[23].

In our view, a separate area for promising research in this field should be the distinction between commercial and public ecosystems, as well as the development of theoretical models for their effective integration. In addition to the state-run “Gosuslugi” ecosystem, current legislation also designates other types of digital platforms and ecosystems whose creation, subsidization, and other forms of support involved state participation[24].

The Strategy for the Development of the Russian Financial Market until 2030 mentions the category of “ecosystems with a financial component”[25]. This seems reasonable, given that many ecosystems that began as financial ecosystems later incorporate digital platforms providing non-financial services. A typical example of ecosystem with a financial component is the banking ecosystem (Uzdenov, 2022).

The criteria for classifying ecosystems may be expanded further, but this is not the purpose of the present study. In our view, it is far more important to identify the typical characteristics of the modern understanding of ecosystems, which would make it possible to develop unified principles and methods for the legal regulation of their functioning.

Problems and Priorities of Ecosystem Legal Regulation

Legal regulation of ecosystems is currently fragmented, piecemeal, and largely confined to regulatory concepts and local strategic planning acts in specific industries.

Representatives of the executive branch emphasize the need to create a regulatory environment conducive to technological development, favorable conditions for effective competition, and safeguards for the security of citizens and service providers, technological sovereignty, and sustainable socio-economic development in the digital economy[26].

It is also important to note that experts identify not only legal but also political risks associated with the functioning of modern ecosystems. Among the legal risks are market oligopolization and threats to user data security. Political risks include the potential to manipulate public opinion, shape the agenda, and censor statements[27].

Despite the emergence of the contours of a modern “sort of ecosystem constitution”[28], these concepts remain vague. Nevertheless, based on an analysis of the current understanding and use of the ecosystem category in modern legislation and legal science, it is possible to identify the problems that legal regulation in this area should address.

Legal regulation of the creation and functioning of ecosystems is fragmented, intersectoral, and transnational in nature, and is aimed at addressing several important issues:

  1. Consumer protection, including ensuring consumers' freedom to move from one ecosystem to another and their freedom to choose an ecosystem.
  2. Competition issues. Two levels of competition should be distinguished: competition within the domestic market and international competition, as well as competition between domestic ecosystems and interactions between national and foreign ecosystems.
  3. Predictability, proportionality, and preventive regulation.
  4. Ensuring information security, including control over content and the protection of users' personal data.
  5. Stimulating innovation, entrepreneurship, and other economic activity, as well as the creation of new ecosystems.
  6. The relationship between business ecosystems and state digital platforms and ecosystems, that is, the state as a digital platform.

Scholars identify several problems in the legal regulation of the functioning and development of ecosystems, including the fluidity of ecosystem boundaries and the difficulty of classifying ecosystems as a separate object of legal regulation (Egorova, 2021:147), as well as the difficulty of classifying ecosystem participants, given the coexistence of a traditional organizational and legal status and the potential for granting the ecosystem a relatively new legal personality, resulting in overlapping statuses (Andreev, 2022), among other issues.

Two main approaches to ecosystem regulation can be distinguished: project-based approach, which designates specific national projects or their components as ecosystems (for example, the National Technology Initiative ecosystem, the digital ecosystem of the Labor Productivity national project, and others), and a targeted approach, which focuses on optimizing existing ecosystems and regulating the interactions among their elements, as well as their connections with other ecosystems.

The functioning and development of ecosystems of various kinds must be monitored by the state. State attention to ecosystems should take the form of preventive regulation, control and supervision of their activities, and, at the same time, stimulation of their development. As part of the development of the Russian financial market, it is envisaged that the Bank of Russia, in cooperation with other regulatory and supervisory bodies, will establish a system for overseeing the activities of ecosystems with a financial component[29].

We believe that the priority in legal regulation of ecosystems should not be specialized regulation that treats the ecosystem as a separate and autonomous object of legal regulation, but rather the optimization of all branches of legislation currently involved in regulating ecosystem functioning. Regulation is needed, first, for interactions within the ecosystem, that is, the corporate aspect; second, for interactions between different ecosystems, that is, the competitive aspect; and third, for interactions between ecosystems and consumers of their values, that is, the consumer protection aspect. At the same time, consumer protection and competition protection measures applied to ecosystems are changing, which requires constant updating of approaches and evaluation criteria.

Particular attention should be paid to information security issues, which cut across all the aspects identified above, both internal and external. Here, the state undoubtedly has a special role.

From a strategic perspective, the state should stimulate the creation of digital platforms, including public ones, by attracting private investment and relying on data from the external ecosystem, which makes the need for digital services more explicit and helps determine the architecture of the digital platform (Samsonova et al., 2022).

Conclusion

With regard to the entrepreneurial ecosystem, scholars rightly note that the inherently “natural” interdisciplinarity of the concept not only permits but also predetermines the use of various methodological approaches to its study, including evolutionary, institutional, contextual, sociocultural, and other approaches. This approach appears applicable to any other type of modern ecosystem as well. Interdisciplinarity thus emerges as a guiding principle in the scientific study of ecosystems.

Ecosystems in modern science have many dimensions: they are regarded as a type of socio-economic system, an independent research approach, a level of analysis, a unit of economic analysis and regulatory framework, a form of economic and other relations, a stage of a company's digital development or maturity, a model of corporate governance, and as a form of economic growth. In this sense, they represent a new generation of economic entities, units of economic analysis, and simultaneously objects of legal regulation.

Our brief analysis makes it possible to identify several existing approaches to the scientific substantiation of ecosystems: traditional, that is, biological; universal, that is treating the ecosystem as a general scientific approach to objects of analysis of any level and nature; digital, according to which an ecosystem is a set of digital platforms or digital services; corporate, where the ecosystem is understood as a model of corporate governance; and others. At the same time, our later scientific interpretations of ecosystems naturally project onto themselves the basic methods used in the study of their original scientific prototype, the natural ecosystem. In this respect, traditional and universal methods developed for natural ecosystems, such as treating them as a new generation of economic, legal, and digital objects and identifying the sustainable functioning of ecosystems with indicators of a favorable and secure digital environment, can be successfully applied to modern digital ecosystems.

An ecosystem creates new value both for consumers and for its own development, which ultimately makes it valuable and beneficial for society as a whole. The need to preserve ecosystem biodiversity has traditionally been justified in relation to natural ecosystems. We believe that, in the socio-economic sphere, the development of ecosystem diversity and the maintenance of their competitive and legally regulated coexistence, in order to effectively protect the rights and legitimate interests of citizens and organizations, should be regarded as priorities for state regulation in this area.

 

1 Digital Ecosystems in Russia: Evolution, Typology, and Approaches to Regulation. Gaidar Institute for Economic Policy. Moscow, 2022. 55 p. https://www.iep.ru/files/news/Issledovanie_jekosistem_Otchet.pdf. [Accessed 20th May 2025].

2 Federal Law “On the Federal Budget for 2023 and for the Planning Period of 2024 and 2025” No. 466-FZ dated 05.12.2022 // Official Internet Portal of Legal Information http://pravo.gov.ru, 05.12.2022.

3 The Ministry of Economic Development has submitted the draft law “On the Platform Economy” to the Government of the Russian Federation. Official website of the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation. https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/news/minekonomrazvitiya_vneslo_zakonoproekt_o_platformennoy_ekonomike_v_pravitelstvo_rf.html [Accessed 20th May 2025].

4 Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary / Editorial Board: A.M. Prokhorov (chairman). Moscow: “Soviet Encyclopedia”, 1981. P. 1550.

5 Ecosystems: Approaches to Regulation. Report for Public Consultations. Moscow, Bank of Russia, 2021. 45 pp. https://cbr.ru/Content/Document/File/119960/Consultation_Paper_02042021.pdf [Accessed 07th May 2025].

6 Decree of the President of the Russian Federation “On the Strategy for the Development of the Information Society in the Russian Federation for 2017-2030” No. 203 dated May 9, 2017 // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, May 15, 2017, No. 20, Art. 2901.

7 Concept for General Regulation of the Activities of Groups of Companies Developing Various Digital Services Based on a Single “Ecosystem” May 2021. 22 pp. Electronic resource. https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/file/cb29a7d08290120645a871be41599850/koncepciya_21052021.pdf. [Accessed 13th May 2025].

8 Ecosystems: Approaches to Regulation. Public Consultation Report. Moscow, Bank of Russia, 2021. 45 pages. https://cbr.ru/Content/Document/File/119960/Consultation_Paper_02042021.pdf [Accessed 06th May 2025].

9 Draft Federal Law “On the Platform Economy in the Russian Federation” (prepared by the Ministry of Economic Development of Russia, Project ID 02/04/11-24/00152517) (not submitted to the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, text as of 22.11.2024) // The text of the document is reproduced in accordance with the version published on the website regulation.gov.ru as of 22.11.2024.

10 Concept of state regulation of digital platforms and ecosystems // https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/departments/d31/koncepciya_gos_regulirovaniya_cifrovyh_platform_i_ekosistem/ [Accessed 06th May 2025].

11 Order of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission “On the list of services and digital infrastructure implemented to form an ecosystem of digital transport corridors of the Eurasian Economic Union” No. 29 dated November 23, 2020 // Official website of the Eurasian Economic Union http://www.eaeunion.org/, December 31, 2020.

12 Concept for general regulation of the activities of groups of companies developing various digital services based on a single “ecosystem”. May, 2021. 22 pp. Electronic resource. https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/file/cb29a7d08290120645a871be41599850/koncepciya_21052021.pdf [Accessed 13th May 2025].

13 Concept of state regulation of digital platforms and ecosystems // https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/departments/d31/koncepciya_gos_regulirovaniya_cifrovyh_platform_i_ekosistem/ [Accessed 06th May 2025].

14 Federal Law “On Environmental Protection” No. 7-FZ dated 10.01.2002 // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, 14.01.2002, No. 2, Art. 133.

15 Titov B. How and why it is necessary to regulate new ecosystems: Advice to the Bank of Russia. Electronic resource. https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/447193-kak-i-zacem-nuzno-regulirovat-novye-ekosistemy-sovety-banku-rossii [Accessed 13th May 2025].

16 Resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation “On Approval of the Rules for Providing a Subsidy from the Federal Budget to Ensure the Creation of a Digital Ecosystem of the Northern Sea Route” No. 8, dated January 12, 2023. // Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation, January 23, 2023, No. 4, Art. 636.

17 Order of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission “On the list of services and digital infrastructure implemented to form an ecosystem of digital transport corridors of the Eurasian Economic Union” No. 29, dated November 23, 2020. // Official website of the Eurasian Economic Union http://www.eaeunion.org/, December 31, 2020.

18 Volkova A. Ecosystem of company personnel: Legal regulation and management. 2023. EZh-Bukhgalter, No. 9. p. 9.

19 Ecosystems: Approaches to regulation. Report for public consultations. Moscow, Bank of Russia, 2021. 45 pp. https://cbr.ru/Content/Document/File/119960/Consultation_Paper_02042021.pdf [Accessed 07th May 2025].

20 Ecosystems: Regulatory Approaches. Public Consultative Report. Moscow, Bank of Russia, 2021. 45 pp. https://cbr.ru/Content/Document/File/119960/Consultation_Paper_02042021.pdf [Accessed 07th May 2025]. P. 4.

21 Concept of General Regulation of the Activities of Groups of Companies Developing Various Digital Services Based on One “Ecosystem.” May, 2021. 22 pp. Electronic resource. P. 4. https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/file/cb29a7d08290120645a871be41599850/koncepciya_21052021.pdf [Accessed 13th May 2025].

22 GOST R 70486-2022. National Standard of the Russian Federation. Unified Technology “Digital Social Lawyer” (approved and put into effect by Order of Rosstandart No. 1360-st dated November 23, 2022,). Moscow: Federal State Budgetary Institution “Institute of Standardization”, 2022.

23 A comprehensive solution to enterprise digitalization challenges. https://efficiency.rf/ [Accessed 08th May 2025].

24 See: RF Government Resolution No. 2439 of 26.12.2022 “On state support for the Russian Export Center Joint-Stock Company, Moscow, in order to create, on the basis of its digital platform, the services of the One-Stop-Shop digital ecosystem within the framework of the socio-economic development initiative of the Russian Federation “The Exporter's One-Stop-Shop Digital Ecosystem”, amending the Rules for providing a subsidy from the federal budget to the Russian Export Center Joint-Stock Company, Moscow, in order to develop infrastructure for enhancing international competitiveness and recognizing as invalid certain provisions of acts of the Russian Government” (together with the “Rules for providing a subsidy from the federal budget to the Russian Export Center Joint-Stock Company, Moscow, in order to create, on the basis of its digital platform, the services of the One-Stop-Shop digital ecosystem within the framework of the socio-economic development initiative of the Russian Federation "The Exporter's One-Stop-Shop Digital Ecosystem”) // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, 02.01.2023, No. 1 (Part I), Article 258.

25 Russian Government Order No. 4355-r of December 29, 2022, “On Approval of the Strategy for the Development of the Financial Market of the Russian Federation until 2030” // Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation, January 2, 2023, No. 1 (Part III), Article 476.

26 Yulia Akinshina, Irina Alpatova. The Ministry of Economic Development Presented a Concept for Ecosystem Regulation. For People and Businesses // Rossiyskaya Gazeta. May 31, 2021. https://rg.ru/2021/05/30/minekonomrazvitiia-predtavilo-koncepciiu-regulirovaniia-ekosistem.html [Accessed 16th May 2025].

27 Anastasia Boyko, Dmitry Grinkevich. The Government is Preparing General Principles for Ecosystem Regulation. Online resource. https://www.vedomosti.ru/economics/characters/2021/09/28/888797-obschie-printsipi-ekosistem [Accessed 16th May 2025].

28 Ibid.

29 Order of the Government of the Russian Federation of 29.12.2022 No. 4355-r “On approval of the Strategy for the Development of the Financial Market of the Russian Federation until 2030” // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, 02.01.2023, No. 1 (Part III), Art. 476.

×

About the authors

Saniyat A. Agamagomedova

Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: saniyat_aga@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-8265-2971
SPIN-code: 6403-7316

Doctor of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor, Senior Researcher of the Administrative Law and Administrative Process Sector

10 Znamenka St., Moscow, 119019, Russian Federation

References

  1. Akatkin, Yu.M., Karpov, O.E., Konyavsky, V.A. & Yasinovskaya, E.D. (2017) Digital Economy: Conceptual Architecture of the Digital Industry Ecosystem. Business Informatics. (4 (42)), 17-28. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.17323/1998-0663.2017.4.17.28 EDN: VXTIPJ.
  2. Andreev, V.K. (2022) On the Ecosystem and Legal Issues of the Digital Economy. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Corporate Law. (1 (25)), 15-19. (In Russian). EDN: HHIKLO.
  3. Barinova, V.A., Zemtsov, S.P. & Tsareva, Yu.V. (2018) Entrepreneurship and institutions: Is there a connection at the regional level in Russia? Issues of Economics. (6), 1-25. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.32609/0042-8736-2018-6-92-116 EDN: XPUDWX.
  4. Brinchuk, M.M. (2012) Natural Ecological Systems and Environmental Law (Part 2). Astrakhan Bulletin of Environmental Education. (3 (21)), 4-17. (In Russian). EDN: PUQKZD.
  5. Christensen, N.L. & Franklin, J.F. (1997) Ecosystem Function and Ecosystem Management. In: Simpson, R.D. & Christensen, N.L. (eds.) Ecosystem Function & Human Activities. Springer, Boston, MA Publ., pp. 1-23. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-6049-4_1
  6. Doroshenko, S.V. & Shelomentsev, A.G. (2017) Entrepreneurial Ecosystem in Contemporary Socioeconomic Research. Journal of Economic Theory. (4), 212-221. (In Russian). EDN: ZVMLAZ.
  7. Egorova, M.A. (2021) Legal conditions for creating digital ecosystems. In: Blazheeva, V.V. & Egorova, M.A. (eds.) Law and society in the era of socio-economic transformations of the 21st century: The experience of Russia, the EU, the USA and China. Moscow, Prospekt Publ., pp. 144-148. (In Russian). EDN: AFPASR.
  8. Gabov, A.V. (2022) Online dispute resolution of participants in digital platforms (ecosystems). Bulletin of the civil process. 12 (1), 208-235. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.24031/2226-0781-2022-12-1-208-235 EDN: KTJCHG.
  9. Gamidullaeva, L.A. & Agamagomedova, S.A. (2021) Entrepreneurial ecosystems: Impact on the quality of life in a region. Global Business and Economics Review. 25 (1), 68-88. https://doi.org/10.1504/GBER.2021.116621 EDN: IMMFWW.
  10. Gavrilov, S.N. (2020) Conceptual and terminological basis of the informational (digital) ecosystem of the legal profession: A conceptual approach to the formation. Advokatskaya praktika. (4), 53-64. (In Russian). EDN: CUKHLK.
  11. Gavrilov, S.N. & Volodina, S.I. (2019) Information (digital) ecosystem of the legal profession in the context of the ecosystem of the digital economy of Russia. Actual problems of Russian law. (6 (103)), 156-166. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2019.103.6.156-166 EDN: CMOGPF.
  12. Gots, E.V. & Bliznets, I.A. (2021) Development of the Digital Ecosystem of Copyright and Related Rights: Fiction or Reality. Lawyer. (9), 12-18. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.18572/1812-3929-2021-9-12-18 EDN: PQEWME.
  13. Grigor’eva, E.A. & Grigor’ev, A.I. (2012) Modern understanding of systemic concepts and terms in ecology. Omsk Scientific Bulletin. (2 (106)), 152-155. (In Russian). EDN: PBDFTL.
  14. Kleiner, G.B. (2018) Socio-economic ecosystems in the light of the system paradigm. In: Kleiner, G.B. & Shchepetova, S.E. (eds.) Proceedings of the V International Scientific and Practical Conference-Biennale. Moscow, Publishing Prometej, pp. 4-14. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.33278/SAE-2018.rus.005-014 EDN: RLWNNS.
  15. Kleiner, G.B. (2019) Economics of ecosystems: A step into the future. Economic revival of Russia. (1 (59)), 40-45. (In Russian). EDN: YYIULJ.
  16. Mikheeva, I.E. (2022) Unfair practices in banking ecosystems. Actual Problems of Russian Law. 17 (7 (140)), 59-70. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2022.140.7.059-070 EDN: ZAWKQM.
  17. Moore, J. F. (1993) Predators and prey: A new ecology of competition. Harvard Business Review. 71 (3), 75-83.
  18. Neang, M., Méral, P., Aznar, O. & Déprés, C. (2019) Correction to: Trade-offs Between Ecosystem Services and Opportunity Costs in Maintaining the Tonle Sap Lake Agro-ecosystem (Cambodia). In: Stewart, M. & Coclanis, P. (eds.) Water and Power. Advances in Global Change Research. 64, 89-114. Cham, Springer Publ. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-90400-9_6
  19. O’Connor, A., Stam, E., Sussan, F. & Audretsch, D.B. (2018) Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: The Foundations of Place-based Renewal. In: O’Connor, A., Stam, E., Sussan, F., Audretsch, D. (eds.) Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. International Studies in Entrepreneurship. Vol. 38. Cham, Springer Publ., pp. 1-21. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-63531-6_1
  20. Samsonova, M.V., Streltsova, E.G., Chaikin, A.V. et al. (2022) Digital technologies in civil and administrative proceedings: practice, analytics, prospects. In: Streltsov, E.G. (ed.) Moscow, Infotropic Media Publ. (In Russian).
  21. Trabskaja, J. & Mets, T. (2019) Ecosystem as the Source of Entrepreneurial Opportunities. Foresight and STI Governance. 13 (4), 10-22. https://doi.org/10.17323/2500-2597.2019.4.10.22
  22. Uzdenov, Sh.Sh. (2022) The concept of a "Bank ecosystem". Banking law. (3), 46-54. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.18572/1812-3945-2022-3-46-54 EDN: RRGGJY.
  23. Whitmore, H.W. (2007) The Government Sectors. In: The World Economy, Population Growth, and the Global Ecosystem. New York, Palgrave Macmillan Publ., pp. 23-46. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230607309_3
  24. Wu, S. & Lin, C.Y. (2019) Introduction. In: Innovation and Entrepreneurship in an Educational Ecosystem. Singapore, Springer Publ., pp. 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-32-9445-5_1

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML

Copyright (c) 2026 Agamagomedova S.A.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.