Creationism - a Pseudoscience or Pseudoreligion
- Authors: Lokhov S.A.1, Mamchenkov D.V.1
-
Affiliations:
- RUDN University
- Issue: Vol 28, No 1 (2024): MAHAYANA BUDDHIST PHILOSOPHY
- Pages: 148-167
- Section: Philosophy and sciences
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/philosophy/article/view/38429
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2313-2302-2024-28-1-148-167
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/AGFZJL
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
The research is devoted to the study of the phenomenon of spiritual culture of Modern times - creationism. Authors analyze the causes of creationist teachings, as well as develop a classification of forms of creationism. As such, the following are distinguished and analyzed: biblical creationism, scientific creationism, theological evolutionism, teleological creationism, alterism, missionary creationism. Biblical creationism is a literal understanding of the texts of the Bible relating to the creation of the Earth and man. Scientific creationism is an attempt by individual scientists to combine scientific knowledge with religious beliefs. It gathers scientific evidence in favor of the biblical narrative, and, at the same time, rational arguments against the scientific theory of evolution. On the contrary, theological evolutionism, especially in the form of concordism, tries to reconcile the scientific and religious view of evolution. This is achieved through the interpretation of Biblical symbols through modern scientific concepts, or by the creation of a new pseudo-religion (for example, Teilhardism). Teleological creationism, in the modern form of Intelligent Design theory, popular in Western Protestantism, using the data of natural sciences, criticizes the foundations of the theory of biological evolution, thus demonstrating the gap of natural causality in order to justify the supernatural purposefulness of the Universe. Alterism asserts that the very nature of the world before original sin was different, therefore, the current knowledge of nature cannot correspond to the original plan of God reflected in the Bible. For the first time, highlighted and explored in this work, missionary creationism seeks to interpret the Bible from the point of view of concepts of modern science in order to bring a person with an already formed scientific picture of the world to faith. It is shown that most of the above forms demonstrate a pseudoscientific or pseudo-religious essence. The authors make an assumption about the origins of creationist teachings rooted in the introduction of elements of Neoplatonic philosophy into Christian teaching. The seeming contradiction between science and religion in understanding the evolution of nature finds its explanation through the disclosure of creationism's claim to understand the world as a "thing in itself".
About the authors
Sergei A. Lokhov
RUDN University
Author for correspondence.
Email: lokhov-sa@rudn.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-9046-601X
PhD in Philosophy, Associate Professor, Department of Ontology and Epistemology, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences
6 Miklukho-Maklaya St., 117198, Moscow, Russian FederationDmitrii V. Mamchenkov
RUDN University
Email: mamchenkov-dv@rudn.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0003-0484-2232
PhD in Philosophy, Associate Professor, Department of Ontology and Epistemology, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences
6 Miklukho-Maklaya St., 117198, Moscow, Russian FederationReferences
- Vasily the Great. Conversations on the sixth day. Creations. Pt. 1. Reprint edition; 1845. (In Russian).
- Seraphim (Rose) hieromonk. Genesis: the creation of the world and the first Old Testament people. Christian Orthodox introduction. Moscow: Izdatel'skij Dom “Russkij palomik” publ.; 2009. (In Russian).
- Bufeev K, Archpriest. The Orthodox Doctrine of Creation and the theory of Evolution. Moscow: Russkij izdatel'skij centr imeni svyatogo Vasiliya Velikogo publ.; 2014. (In Russian).
- Sysoev D, the priest. The chronicle began. Biblical history and modern science. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Sretenskogo monastyrya publ.; 1999. (In Russian).
- Timothy (Alfyorov), the priest. Two cosmogonies. Moscow: Pilgrim publ.; 1998. (In Russian).
- Lyulka AV. Are the “Orthodox” evolutionists right? In: Almanac “Orthodoxy”. Issue II. Moscow: Blagotvoritel'nyj fond Missionerskoe dvizhenie svyatyh pervoverhovnyh apostolov Petra i Pavla publ.; 2013. (In Russian).
- Father Seraphim (Rose). The Orthodox view of evolution. Collection of tr. fr. Serafim Platinsky. 4th ed. Moscow: Bratstvo Prepodob. Germana Alyaskinskogo Platina publ., Kaliforniya: Russkij Palomnik: Ros. otd-nie Valaam. Ob-va Ameriki publ.; 2003. (In Russian).
- Zenko YuM. Is man a microcosm or an image of God? Critical and comparative analysis of ideas. Saint Petersburg: TSHPA, LLC "Contrast" publ.; 2020. (In Russian).
- Sokolov A. Myths about human evolution. Moscow: Alpina non-fiction publ.; 2019. (In Russian).
- Olkhovsky VS. How do the postulates of faith of evolutionism and creationism relate to each other and modern scientific data. Available from: http://www.origins.org.ua/page.php?id_story=265 (accessed: 09.09.2023). (In Russian).
- Pavlenko AN. The anthropic principle: origins and consequences in European scientific rationality. Filosofsko-religioznye istoki nauki. Moscow; 1997. Available from: https://iphras.ru/page49927401.htm (accessed: 09.09.2023). (In Russian).
- Lalomov AV. Problematic issues of scientific creationism. In: Orthodox understanding of the creation of the world and modern science. Issue 4. Moscow: NP MPC “Shestodnev” publ.; 2008. P. 178—191. (In Russian).
- Stepin VS. History and philosophy of science: A textbook for graduate students and applicants for the degree of Candidate of Sciences. 2nd ed. Moscow: Akademicheskij proekt publ.; Trista publ.; 2012. (In Russian).
- Hramov AV. Monkey and Adam. Can a Christian be an evolutionist? Moscow: Nikeya publ.; 2019. (In Russian).
- Schloss JP. Evolutionary Theory and Religious Belief. Oxford Handbook of Science and Religion. OUP. 2006. P. 187—206.
- Augustine the Blessed. About the Book of Genesis literally. Available from: https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/Avrelij_Avgustin/o-knige-bytija (accessed: 17.09.2023). (In Russian).
- Teilhard de Chardin P. Le Phénomène humain. Moscow: Iris Press; 2002. (In Russian).
- Bradley W, Olsen R, Thaxton C. The Mystery of life’s Origin; Reassessing Universe. San Francisco: Ignatius Press; 1984.
- Denton M. Evolution: A Theory in Crisis. Bethesda: Adler & Adler; 1985.
- Behe M. Darwin’s Black Box: the Biochemical Challenge to Evolution. N.Y.; 1996.
- Danilevsky NY. Darwinism. Critical research. Moscow: FIV publ.; 2015. (In Russian).
- Nazarov VI. Evolution not according to Darwin: Changing the evolutionary model: Textbook. Moscow: KomKniga publ.; 2005. (In Russian).
- Priest Sergey Krivovichev. Orthodoxy and Natural Sciences: textbook of Bachelor of theology. Moscow: Obshchecerkovnaya aspirantura i doktorantura im. Svyatyh ravnoapostol'nyh Kirilla i Mefodiya, Izdatel'skij dom «Poznanie» publ.; 2022. (In Russian).
- Bishop Vasily (Rodzianko). The theory of the disintegration of the universe and the faith of the fathers. Moscow: Pilgrim publ.; 2003. (In Russian).
- Nikonov NI. The mystery of the sixth day: days of Creation or millions of years? Saint Petersburg: Ladan — Troickaya shkola publ.; 2008. (In Russian).
- Serebryakov NS. The problem of the correlation of the biblical narrative about the creation of the world and man with scientific natural science. In: All wisdom was created by you.. The works of the PSTPU seminar "Science and Faith". Issue 1. Moscow: Publishing House of PSTSU; 2001. P. 88—111. (In Russian).
- Barth K. Der Römerbrief. Moscow: BBI publ.; 2016. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy EN. The meaning of life. In: The meaning of life in Russian philosophy. The end of the XIX — the beginning of the XX century. Saint Petersburg: Nauka publ.; 1995. (In Russian).
- Berdyaev N. Self-knowledge. Moscow: Kniga publ.; 1991. (In Russian).
- Kuraev AV[17]. Can an Orthodox be an evolutionist. Moscow: Fond “Hristianskaya zhizn” publ.; 2006. (In Russian).
- Anthony, Metropolitan of Surozh. Confidence in invisible things. Recent conversations (2001—2002). Moscow: Duhovnoe nasledie mitropolita Antonij: Nikeya publ.; 2012. (In Russian).
- Hart DB. God. New answers at the borders of reason. Moscow: Eksmo publ.; 2019. (In Russian).
- Parkhomenko K, archpriest. Creation of the world and man. Moscow: DAR publ.; 2010. (In Russian).
- Neifakh George, archpriest. The harmony of Divine creation. The relationship between science and religion. Moscow: Pravilo very publ.; 2013. (In Russian).
- Kiryanov D, priest. Some approaches to solving the problem of the relationship between evolutionary teaching and Christian theology. Available from: https://bogoslov.ru/article/391612 (accessed: 21.09.2023). (In Russian).
- Lokhov SA. The Christian ethics of love (a look through the prism of philosophical anthropology). RUDN Journal of Philosophy. 2013;(3):103—111. (In Russian).
- Camus A. Christian Metaphysics and Neoplatonism. Srigley R, transl. Columbia and London: University of Missouri Press; 2007.
- Larson J. Albert Camus on Christian Metaphysics and Neoplatonism. Prajna Vihara. 2011;12(2):55—75.
- Kant I. Critique of Pure Reason. Simferopol: Renome publ.; 2003. (In Russian).
- Pinker S. Blank slate: Human Nature. Who and why refuses to recognize it today. Moscow: Alpina non-fiction publ.; 2019. (In Russian).
- Sapolsky R. Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst. Moscow: Alpina non-fiction publ.; 2020. (In Russian).
- Wilson E. On human nature. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole publ.; 2015. (In Russian).