Formation of modern regional judiciary in Russia: a case study of courts of general jurisdiction of Novosibirsk Oblast

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

This study outlines results of the study on regional judiciary conducted in the Novosibirsk Oblast and summarizes analysis on its socio-demographic and professional composition and sources of formation. The study is interdisciplinary in nature; sociological (questionnaires and in-depth interviews) and legal research methods (historical and legal, formal legal, comparative legal) have been applied, 192 judges of courts of general jurisdiction of the Novosibirsk Oblast have been interviewed during the research. The analysis of the outcome of the study shows that a modern regional judge is a young woman who received a full-time legal education at a classical university and has a predominant professional experience in court. The study acknowledges further rejuvenation and feminization of the regional judiciary, due to specifics of personnel policy. The dominant source of replenishment of the regional corps of judges is the court apparatus; this method is most significant for the formation of justices of the peace (JPs) and judges of district courts. The main reasons for the predominance of representatives from the court apparatus in the judiciary corps are the scope of work and requirements for the professional qualities of a judge, among which adaptability to high workloads, significant amount of paperwork, control over procedural deadlines, and effective compliance with the key indicators of the judge’s work form the core. We believe that the trend to form the judiciary mainly through internal sources may negatively affect the authority and status of the judicial profession.

About the authors

Marina S. Salamatova

Novosibirsk State University of Economics and Management

Author for correspondence.
Email: salamatova.m@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-5780-8815

Candidate of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, Head of the Department of Theory and History of State and Law, Faculty of Law

56 Kamenskaya str., Novosibirsk, 630099, Russian Federation

References

  1. Burdin, D.A. (2014) Genesis of the system formation Russian judiciary. Modern Law. (6), 96-101. (in Russian).
  2. Burdin, D.A. (2015) Modern models of formation judiciary in foreign countries. Law and Politics. (3), 368-372. https://doi.org/10.7256/1811-9018.2015.3.14433 (in Russian).
  3. Daminev, I.I. (2021) Recruitment of the judiciary in Russia. Issues of Science and Education. (9), 18-22. (in Russian).
  4. Dmitrieva, A.V., Pozdnyakov, M. L., Titaev, K. D. (2012) Russian judges as a professional group. Sociological study. Volkov, V.V. (ed.). Saint Petersburg, Institute of Law Enforcement Problems of the European University in Saint Petersburg Publ. (in Russian).
  5. Dmitrieva, A. & Saveliev, D. (2018) Sources of replenishment of the judicial corps of the Russian Federation and the role of the court apparatus. Saint Petersburg, Institute of Law Enforcement Problems of the European University in Saint Petersburg. (in Russian).
  6. Dorskaya, A.A. (2013) Concept of “legal traditions” within the system of Russian judicial law: institutional and content aspects. Law and Education. (10), 4-12. (in Russian).
  7. Faroi, T.V. (2019) Legal scholars on the shortcomings of the system of formation of the judiciary in the Russian Federation. Kuban Agency Judicial Information PRO-SUD-123.RU: Legal network electronic scientific journal. 1(8), 124-146. (in Russian).
  8. Ivanova, E. (2015) Gender imbalance in Russian judiciary: feminization of profession. Journal of Social policy studies. 13.(4), 579-594. (in Russian).
  9. Ilyina, T.N. (2019) Traditions of legal education and legal profession in Russia and abroad: experience of interaction. Historical and legal problems: a new perspective. (3), 31-37. (in Russian).
  10. Kuhn, Z. (2004) Worlds apart: western and central european judicial culture at the onset of the european enlargement. The American Journal of Comparative Law. 52(3), 531-567, https://doi.org/10.2307/4144478
  11. Kleandrov, M.I. (2009) On legislative support of the mechanism of formation of judiciary in the Russian Federation. State and Law. (5), 31-41. (in Russian).
  12. Kleandrov, M.I. (2019) Judiciary of Russia: improving the mechanism of formation. Moscow, INFRA-M Publ. (in Russian).
  13. Klyukin, S.I. (2015) On ways of forming the judiciary during new judicial establishments. Laws of Russia: experience, analysis, practice. (4), 63-67. (in Russian).
  14. Kornakova, S.V. & Shcherbakova, I.A. (2019) Problems of Legal Regulation of the Judiciary Formation Procedure. Bulletin of Tomsk State University. (443), 255-259. (in Russian).
  15. Lonskaya, S.V., Fadeeva, E.S. & Plotnikova, E.O. (2021a) Professional subculture of magistrates (based on the results of study in the Kaliningrad region). Part 1. Magistrate judge. (9), 3-9. https://doi.org/10.18572/2072-4152-2021-9-3-9 (in Russian).
  16. Lonskaya, S.V., Fadeeva, E.S. & Plotnikova, E.O. (2021b) Professional subculture of magistrates (based on the results of study in the Kaliningrad region). Part 2. Magistrate judge. (10), 2-6. https://doi.org/10.18572/2072-4152-2021-10-2-6 (in Russian).
  17. Orlov, A.V. (2017). Staffing of judicial bodies: some problematic issues and their solutions. Russian judge. (1), 38-43. (in Russian).
  18. Schwartz, O. & Sykiainen, E. (2012) Judicial independence in the Russian Federation. In: Seibert-Fohr, A. (eds.). Judicial independence in transition. Beiträge zum ausländischen öffentlichen Recht und Völkerrecht. Vol. 233. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. pp. 971-1064. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-28299-7_24
  19. Schultz, U. The Status of Women Lawyers in Germany, Women in World’s Legal Profession (eds. by U. Schultz, G. Shaw). Oxford, 2003: 269-294.
  20. Schultz U. & Shaw G. (eds.) (2013) Introduction: Gender and Judging: Overview and Syn­thesis. U. Schultz, G. Shaw (eds.). Gender and Judging, Oxford: Hart: 7-14.
  21. Serov, D.O. (2013) Russian judges and higher legal education. Higher education in Russia. (10). 77-82. (in Russian).
  22. Shepeleva, O. & Novikova, A. (2013) The quality of legal education: stereotypes and the real problems. Legal education: search for new quality standards. Moscow: Institute of Public Interest Law (PILnet). 15-34. (in Russian).
  23. Solomon, P.H. (2008) Assessing the Courts in Russia: Parameters of Progress under Putin. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization. 16 (1), 63-73.
  24. Solomon, P.H. (2012) The Accountability of Judges in Post Communist States: From Bureaucratic to Professional Accountability. In: Seibert-Fohr, A. (eds.). Judicial Independence in Transition. Beiträge zum ausländischen öffentlichen Recht und Völkerrecht. Vol. 233. Springer, Berlin. pp. 909-935. Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-28299-7_22
  25. Solomon, P.H. & Foglesong, T. (2000) Courts and Transition in Russia. The Challenge of Judicial Reform. Boulder, Westview Press.
  26. Telegina, V.A. (2020) One of problems of forming the judiciary. Bulletin of the Saratov State Law Academy. 2(133), 57-62. https://doi.org/10.24411/2227-7315-2020-10037 (in Russian).
  27. Vlasova, G.B. (2008) The Judiciary in judicial systems of foreign countries. Jurist-Pravoved. 5(30), 89-93. (in Russian).
  28. Volkov, V. & Dmitrieva, A. (2015) Sources of recruitment, gender and professional subcultures in the Russian judicial system. Sociology of power. 27(2), 94-134. (in Russian).
  29. Volkov, V.V., Dmitrieva, A.V., Pozdnyakov, M.L. & Titaev, K.D. (2015) Russian judges as a professional group. A sociological study. Moscow, Norma Publ. (in Russian).
  30. Yermoshin, G.T. (2015) Formation judiciary in the Russian Federation: theoretical and practical issues. Russian Justice. (11), 60-67. (in Russian).
  31. Yermoshin, G.T. (2017) Judge and the state: problems of regulation of official (labor) legal relations. Journal of Russian Law. (5) 142-150. (in Russian).
  32. Zakharov, V.V. & Ilyina, T.N. (2012) The system of personnel training for judicial authorities in Russia in the second half of the XIX-early XX century. Moscow, INFRA-M Publ. (in Russian).

Copyright (c) 2023 Salamatova M.S.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies