Bargaining inequality: ways to overcome it in international commercial law and in private international law
- Authors: Fonotova O.V.1, Belyaeva L.E.1
-
Affiliations:
- National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
- Issue: Vol 27, No 4 (2023)
- Pages: 1043-1064
- Section: JUSTICE IN RUSSIA AND FOREIGN COUNTRIES
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/law/article/view/36902
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2313-2337-2023-27-4-1043-1064
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/LYJSXS
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
The basic tenet of contract law is freedom of contract, including the freedom to negotiate and the autonomy of the will of the parties. However, practice and doctrine show that many international commercial contracts are formed in conditions of actual inequality of counterparties. The present work is the first comprehensive study of the problem of cross-border bargaining inequality among professional merchants. The aim of the study is to systematize and critically evaluate the effectiveness of legal conditions formulated in the unified acts of international commercial law and private international law to overcome inequality of counterparties at the pre-contractual stage. The study is based on logical, formal-legal and comparative-legal methods. The results and conclusions may be formulated as follows: (1) The set of legal means to resolve the problem of unequal position of the contracting parties is represented by a complex of complementary spheres of unified normative regulation - substantive norms and conflict-of-law norms. (2) Universal conventional legal regulation of the pre-contractual stage has not been developed. (3) Recommendatory acts of substantive unification of commercial law enshrine developed models of regulation of the parties’ conduct in cross-border negotiations. The main legal means to balance the position of the counterparties is the institution of the pre-contractual liability based on the principle of good faith. (4) Both in European law and in Russian law, the conflict-of-law issue is resolved through a combination of non-contractual qualification of the pre-contractual relations and the complex nature of regulation involving the consecutive use of contractual and tort-based connecting factors. (4) Where there is inequality, conflict-of-laws must provide for an equitable solution to situations where the choice of law applicable to each of the contracting parties is not truly free, including permitting a deviation from the principle of autonomy of will. (5) In the absence of parties’ choice of applicable law, the list of criteria for establishing the closest connection between the pre-contractual legal relation and the competent legal order should be expanded: the court should be able to consider the law of the future contractual obligations’ place of performance and the law governing other related contracts.
About the authors
Olga V. Fonotova
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
Author for correspondence.
Email: Olga.Fonotova@gmail.com
ORCID iD: 0000-0003-2255-9684
SPIN-code: 9663-0526
ResearcherId: AAD-6529-2019
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor of the Department of Legal Regulation of Business, Faculty of Law
20 Myasnitskaya str., Moscow, 101000, Russian FederationLidiya E. Belyaeva
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
Email: lesalygina@edu.hse.ru
ORCID iD: 0009-0007-8183-5112
SPIN-code: 6313-4860
ResearcherId: HSF-0270-2023
Department of Legal Regulation of Business, Faculty of Law
20 Myasnitskaya str., Moscow, 101000, Russian FederationReferences
- Bonell, M. J. (2018) The Law Governing International Commercial Contracts and the Actual Role of the UNIDROIT Principles. Uniform Law Review. 23 (1), 15-41.
- Boyarskiy, D.A. (2022) Civil law regulation of negotiations on the conclusion of an entrepreneurial contract: Dis. … Cand. of legal sciences. Ekaterinburg, Ural State University of Law. (in Russian).
- Carrigan, F. (2013) The trivial nature of strict legalism. Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal. 13(1), 1-7.
- Gava, J. (2013) Contract law and inequality - a response to Frank Carrigan. Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal. 13 (1), 9-15.
- Getman-Pavlova, I.V. (2023) Private international law. In: General part: textbook for universities. In 3 Vols. Vol.1. Moscow, Yurait Publ. (in Russian).
- Gnitsevich, K.V. (2009) Pre-contractual liability in Russian civil law. Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court. (3), 31-41.
- Grebelsky, A.V. (2021) International Commercial Arbitration and state courts: allies or opponents? Arbitration court. (2), 16-23. (in Russian).
- Guillemard, S. (1994) Qualification juridique de la négociation d’un contrat et nature de l’obligation de bonne foi. Revue générale de droit. 25(1), 49-82.
- Hage-Chahine, N. (2012) Culpa in Contrahendo in European Private International Law: Another Look at Article 12 of the Rome II Regulation. Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business. 32(3), 451-540.
- Ihering, R. (2013) Culpa in contrahendo or compensation for losses in case of invalidity or non-conclusion of contracts. Civil law Review. (3), 190-266. (in Russian).
- Karapetov, A.G. & Saveliev, A.I. (2012) Freedom of contract and its limits. Vol. 1: Theoretical, historical and political-legal foundations of the principle of freedom of contract and its limitations. Moscow, Statut Publ. (in Russian).
- Marysheva, N.I. (2016) Modern trends of conflicts of laws regulation of tort liabilities: EU Regulation of 2007 “On the law applicable to non-contractual obligations” (Rome II) and the Russian legislation. Journal of Russian Law. (6), 63-73. (in Russian).
- Mazur, O.V. (2012) Pre-contractual liability: analysis of certain features of behaviour in bad faith. Zakon. (5), 197-205. (in Russian).
- McKendrick, E. (2019). Contract Law. Macmillan Law Masters. 13th Edition. Red Globe Press London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-14657-4
- Michaels, R., Ruiz Abou-Nigm, V. & van Loon H. (eds.). (2021) The Private Side of Transforming our World - UN Sustainable Development Goals 2030 and the Role of Private International Law. Intersentia Online. Режим доступа: https://www.intersentiaonline.com/library/the-private-side-of-transforming-our-world-un-sustainable-development-goals-2030-and-the-role-of-p.
- Moura Dário, V. (2003) Precontractual Liability in Private International Law: A Portuguese Perspective. Rabels Zeitschrift für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht. The Rabel Journal of Comparative and International Private Law. 67(4), 699-725. https://doi.org/10.1628/0033725053723550
- Muratova, O.V. (2015) Pre-contractual relations in international commercial turnover: from substantive to conflict of laws regulation: Dis. … Cand. Of legal sciences. Moscow, Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation. (in Russian).
- Muratova, O.V. (2019) Practical experience of resolution of precontractual disputes, arising in the international commercial turnover. Journal of Russian Law. (3), 82-97. (in Russian).
- Nam, K.V. (2019) Principle of good faith. System and randomness. Civil law Review. (1), 28-74. (un Russian).
- Нам К.В. Принцип добросовестности. Система и бессистемность // Вестник гражданского права. 2019. № 1. С. 28-74.
- Novoselova, A.A. & Lomakina, E.V. (2014) Limits of freedom of contract in international commercial relations. International public and private law. (1), 9-13. (in Russian).
- Pistor, K. (2019) The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality. Princeton University Press.
- Puginskiy, B.I. & Amirov, A.T. (2023) Modern Lex Mercatoria: Textbook. Moscow, Zertsalo-M. Publ. (in Russian).
- Stepanisheva, A.M. (2015) Legal regulation and qualification of pre-contractual relations in private international law: Dis. … Cand. of legal sciences. Moscow, Moscow state legal acad. them. O.E. Kutafina. (in Russian).
- Schwenzer, I. (2016) Global Unification of Contract Law. Uniform Law Review. 21(1), 60-74.
- Volos, A.A. & Volos, E.P. (2019) Weak party in civil legal relationship: comparative legal research. Moscow, Prospect Publ. (in Russian).
- Zhang, Mo. (2009) Party Autonomy in Non-Contractual Obligations: Rome II and its Impacts on Choice of Law. Seton Hall Law Review. (39), 861-917.
- Zykin, I.S. (2016) The Hague Principles on the choice of applicable law to international commercial contracts. In: Komarov A.S. (ed.). Actual legal aspects ofmodern practice of international turnover. Moscow, Statut Publ. (in Russian).
- Zykin, I.S., Asoskov, A.V. & Zhyltsov, A.N. (eds.). (2021) Commentary to Section VI “Private International Law” of Part Three of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (article-by-article). S.S. Alekseev Research and Development Center under the President of the Russian Federation. Moscow, Statut Publ. (in Russian).