Eurasian Structuralism
- 作者: Shabaga A.V.1
-
隶属关系:
- Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University)
- 期: 卷 22, 编号 1 (2022): Eurasian Ideology and Eurasian Integration
- 页面: 43-59
- 栏目: THEMATIC DOSSIER
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/international-relations/article/view/30678
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2313-0660-2022-22-1-43-59
如何引用文章
详细
The article examines the socio-political consequences of the structural-linguistic concepts of N.P. Trubetskoy and R.O. Jacobson, as well as the structural-geographical theory of P.N. Savitsky. These scientists, who were the pioneers of the structuralism of the twentieth century, were at the same time the founders of the Eurasian movement, which tried to compete with the Bolshevik doctrine in 1920-1930s. The sociolinguistic principle of “linguistic unions” and the morphological concept postulated by N.S. Trubetskoy became the basis for the semantic picture of the Eurasian space proposed by R.O. Jacobson, which resulted in a socio-political development construct that has not exhausted its potential so far. The morphological and phonological approaches of these two linguists were supported by the structural-geographical concept of P.N. Savitsky, who showed the prerequisites for the emergence of a Eurasian community not only at the linguistic, but also at the geographical and economic levels. Linguists pointed to the connection between language and thinking, which forms the idea of extant and due, which gave arguments for the assertion of the axiological proximity of the Eurasian peoples. Geographer P.N. Savitsky confirmed these conclusions with his research on the formation of the economic kinship of the population of Eurasia on the basis of a single space. Using these concepts, Russian structuralists created a socio-political doctrine about the special role of Eurasia, its separate path, opposite to the western direction of development. Applying certain provisions of F. de Saussure, the founders of Eurasianism created the teleological syntagma ideocracy - demotia - soviet, which determined the structure of the Eurasian socio-political space. The combination of elements of the Eurasian structure is interpreted collinearly of the triad proposed by F. de Saussure langage - langue - parole. The ideocratic system, verified by demotia, determines the activities of the soviets. It follows from this that the teleological syntagma of the Eurasianists, ideocracy - demotia - soviet, was the antithesis of the Bolshevik syntagma communism - Soviet authority - soviet. Ideocracy here is the opposition to communism, and demotia is opposition to Soviet authority. Thus, the structure of the Eurasian state was finally determined. Ideocracy was understood by the Eurasians as a political system, demotia, as a way of social control of the system, and in this case soviets were supposed to become an instrument of self-government, uniting the structure of the Eurasian state from top to bottom.
作者简介
Andrei Shabaga
Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University)
编辑信件的主要联系方式.
Email: shabaga-av@rudn.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7610-9721
PhD, Dr. of Sc. (Philosophy), Professor, Department of Theory and History of International Relations
Moscow, Russian Federation参考
- Alekseev, N. N. (1927a). Note about the court. In P. N. Savitsky (Ed.), Eurasian chronicle. Iss. IX (pp. 16-22). Paris. (In Russian).
- Alekseev, N. N. (1927b). Soviet federalism. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals. Non-periodic edition (Vol. 5, pp. 240-262). Paris: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Alekseev, N. N. (1931). Contemporary challenges in jurisprudence. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 213-220). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Barthes, R. (1975). The foundations of semiology. In E. Ya. Basin & M. Ya. Polyakov (Eds.), Structuralism: “Pro” and “contra”: collection of articles (pp. 114-163). Moscow: Progress publ. (In Russian).
- Berdyaev, N. A. (1925). Eurasians. Put’, (1), 134-139. (In Russian).
- Bitsilli, P. M. (1922). “East” and “West” in the history of the Old World. In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), On the ways. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. 2, pp. 317-340). Moscow - Berlin: Gelikon publ. (In Russian).
- Bogdanov, A. A. (1922). Tectology - universal organizational science. Berlin - St. Petersburg. (In Russian).
- Chkheidze, K. A. (1927). League of Nations and the Mainland States. In P. N. Savitsky (Ed.), Eurasian chronicle (Iss. VIII, pp. 32-35). Paris. (In Russian).
- Chkheidze, K. A. (1931). From the field of Russian geopolitics. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 105-114). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Chomsky, N. (2006). Language and mind. New York: Cambridge University Press.
- Danilevsky, N. Y. (2015). Russia and Europe. A look at the cultural and political relations of the Slavic world to the German-Roman. Moscow: Akademicheskii Proekt publ. (In Russian).
- Dugin, A. G. (1999). Overcoming the West (essay about Nikolai Sergeyevich Trubetskoy). In N. S. Trubetskoy, Heritage of Genghis Khan (pp. 5-25). Moscow: Agraf publ. (In Russian).
- Glebov, S. (2010). Eurasianism between the Empire and Modern: The history in the documents. Moscow: Novoe izdatel’stvo publ. (In Russian).
- Haushofer, K. (2001). On geopolitics. Works of different years. Moscow: Mysl’ publ. (In Russian).
- Heidegger, M. (1998). Gesamtausgabe. III. Abteilung: Unveröffentlichte abhandlungen Vorträge - Gedachtes. Band 69. Frankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klostermann GmbH.
- Herzen, A. I. (1957). Collected works: in 30 volumes (Vol. 11, pp. 9-538). Moscow: Izd-vo Akademii nauk SSSR publ. (In Russian).
- Humboldt, W. (1822). Über die Entstehung der grammatischen Formen und ihren Einfluss auf die Ideenentwicklung. Berlin.
- Ilyin, Vl. (1909). Materialism and empirio-criticism. Critical comments on a reactionary philosophy. Moscow: Zveno publ. (In Russian).
- Jacobson, R. O. (1931a). Report by R.O. Jacobson. About phonological language conjunctions. In Eurasia in the light of linguistics (pp. 7-12). Prague. (In Russian).
- Jacobson, R. O. (1931b). To the characteristics of the Eurasian language union. Paris. (In Russian).
- Jacobson, R. O. (1996). Language and the unconscious (works of different years). Moscow: Gnozis publ. (In Russian).
- Jacobson, R. O. (2012). Budetlyanin of science. Memoirs, letters, articles, poems, prose. Moscow: Gileya publ. (In Russian).
- Karsavin, L. P. (1926). Reply to Berdyaev article about Eurasians. Put’, (2), 124-127. (In Russian).
- Karsavin, L. P. (1927). Basics of politics. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals. Non-periodic edition (Vol. 5, pp. 185-239). Paris: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Karsavin, L. P. (1929). Socialism and Russia. Eurasia, (8), 1-2. (In Russian).
- Kiesewetter, A. A. (1925). Eurasianism. In S. N. Prokopovich (Ed.), Russian economic collection (Vol. 3, pp. 50-65). Prague: Izdanie Ekonomicheskogo kabineta pri Kul’turno-prosvetitel’skom otdele Zemgora publ. (In Russian).
- Kjellén, R. (1917). Der Staat als Lebensform. Leipzig: S. Hirzel.
- Korabelnikova, L. Z. (1999). Alexander Cherepnin. Long journey. Moscow: Yazyki russkoi kultury publ. (In Russian).
- Leontiev, K. N. (1996). A.I. Koshelev and commune in the Moscow magazine “Russian Thought”. In K. N. Leontiev (Ed.), East, Russia and Slavdom (pp. 262-267). Moscow: Respublika publ. (In Russian).
- Logovikov, P. V. (1931a). The power of the organizational idea. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 129-134). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Logovikov, P. V. (1931b). Scientific tasks of Eurasianism. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 53-63). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Lubenskii, S. (1931). Eurasian bibliography 1921-1931. Guide to Eurasian Literature. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 285-317). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Mackinder, H. J. (1904). The geographical pivot of history. The Geographical Journal, XXIII (4), 421-437.
- Mackinder, H. J. (1919). Democratic ideals and reality: A study in the politics of reconstruction. New York: Holt.
- Milyukov, P. N. (1921). History of the Second Russian revolution (Vol. I, Iss. I: Contradictions of the revolution). Sofia: Rossiisko-bolgarskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Naumann, F. (1916). Mitteleuropa. Berlin.
- Parvus, A. L. (1906). Russia and revolution. St. Petersburg. (In Russian).
- Sadovsky, Ya. D. (1923). To opponents of Eurasianism (Letter by Ya.D. Sadovsky to the editorial board). In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 3, pp. 149-179). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Saussure, F. (1971). Сours de linguistique générale. Paris: Payot.
- Saussure, F. (2000). Writings in general linguistics. Moscow: Izdatelskaya gruppa “Progress” publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1921a). Europe and Eurasia (Regarding the brochure of N.S. Trubetskoy “Europe and Humanity”). Russian Thought, (1-2), 119-138. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1921b). Continent-Ocean (Russia and the world market). In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky, N. S. Trubetskoy & G. V. Florovsky (Eds.), Exodus to the East. Premonition and accomplishment. Statement of Eurasians (pp. 104-125). Sofia: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1922). Steppe and settled way of life. In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), On the ways. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. 2, pp. 341-356). Moscow - Berlin: Gelikon publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1923). Nationality of an idea. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 3, pp. 9-17). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1925a). Eurasianism. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 4, pp. 5-23). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1925b). Owner and household. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 4, pp. 406-445). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1928). About issues of nomad studies (Why Scythians and Huns must be of interest for Russians?). Prague: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1931a). In the struggle for Eurasianism. Controversy around Eurasianism in the 1920s. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 1-52). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1931b). Chapters from the “Essay of the Geography of Russia”. In Thirties. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. VII, pp. 87-104). Paris: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Savitsky, P. N. (1932). Five-year plan and economic development of the country. Novyi Grad, (5), 43-55. (In Russian).
- Sombart, W. (1987). Der moderne Kapitalismus. Historisch-systematische Darstellung des gesamteuropäischen Wirtschaftslebens von seinen Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart. Bd. 1-3. Munich: Dtv Reprint.
- Struve, P. B. (1922). Past, present, future. Thoughts on the national revival of Russia. Russian Thought, (1-2), 222-231. (In Russian).
- Sutormin, S. O. (2014). The concept of topogenesis of the Eurasian dimension in the scientific heritage of G.V. Vernadsky and P.N. Savitsky. Tomsk State University Journal, (384), 126-131. (In Russian).
- Suvchinsky, P. P. (1922). Eternal foundation. In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), On the ways. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. 2, pp. 99-133). Moscow - Berlin: Gelikon publ. (In Russian).
- Taube, M. F. (1910). Formation of great power units. Petrograd. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1920). Europe and humanity. Sofia. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1921a). Tops and bottoms of Russian culture (Ethnic base of Russian culture). In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), Exodus to the East. Premonition and accomplishment. Statement of Eurasians (pp. 86-103). Sofia: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1921b). On true and false nationalism. In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), Exodus to the East. Premonition and accomplishment. Statement of Eurasians (pp. 71-85). Sofia: Izdanie evraziitsev publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1922). “Russian problem”. In P. N. Savitsky et al. (Eds.), On the ways. Statement of Eurasians (Vol. 2, pp. 294-316). Moscow - Berlin: Gelikon publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1923a). Babel tower and confusion of languages. In In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 3, pp. 107-124). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1923b). Temptations of unity. In M. N. Burnashev (Ed.), Russia and Latinism: collection of articles (pp. 9-15). Berlin. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1925a). We and others. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 4, pp. 66-81). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1925b). Legacy of Genghis Khan. A look at Russian history not from the West, but from the East. Berlin. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1925c). About the Turanian element in Russian culture. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals (Vol. 4, pp. 351-377). Berlin: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1927a). About the state system and form of government. In P. N. Savitsky (Ed.), Eurasian chronicle (Iss. VIII, pp. 3-20). Paris. (In Russian).
- Trubetskoy, N. S. (1927b). Pan-Eurasian nationalism. In P. N. Savitsky (Ed.), Eurasian chronicle (Iss. IX, pp. 24-30). Paris. (In Russian).
- Ustryalov, N. (1921). Fragments (On the reason of law and the law of history). Smena vekh, (1), 6-8. (In Russian).
- Vernadsky, G. V. (1927). Mongol yoke in Russian history. In P. N. Savitsky, P. P. Suvchinsky & N. S. Trubetskoy (Eds.), Eurasian annals. Non-periodic edition (Vol. 5, pp. 153-164). Paris: Evraziiskoe knigoizdatelstvo publ. (In Russian).
- Vidal de la Blache, P. (2020). Geographic pictures of France. Moscow: ООО “VASH FORMAT” publ. (In Russian).
- Vishnevetsky, I. G. (2005). The “Eurasianist tendency” in the music of the 1920s and 1930s. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie publ. (In Russian).
- Weber, M. (1934). Die protestantische Ethik und der „Geist“ des Kapitalismus. Tübingen: Mohr.
- Whorf, B. L. (1941). The relation of habitual thought and behavior to language. In L. Spier, A. I. Hallowell & S. S. Newman (Eds.), Language, culture, and personality: Essay in memory of Edward Sapir (pp. 197-215). Menasha, Wisconsin: Sapir Memorial Publication Fund.
- Zolotukhin, D. S. (2016). Ferdinand de Saussure’s terminological triad “langue - language - parole” in the works of various authenticity levels. Prepodavatel XXI vek, (3-2), 329-334. (In Russian).