The Conservative Turn in Memory Policies of the the Republic of Korea
- Authors: Kim N.N.1,2
-
Affiliations:
- Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences
- Lomonosov Moscow State University
- Issue: Vol 16, No 1 (2024)
- Pages: 41-63
- Section: Ideas and politics in history
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/world-history/article/view/38724
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2312-8127-2024-16-1-41-63
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/FWPZME
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
The subject of the study is public disagreements on certain issues of Korean history. The study aims to determine the theoretical principles underlying the memory policies of the conservative government of Yun Seokyeol. On the example of the controversy over the transfer of the bust of the Korean independence movement fighter Hong Beomdo and the restoration of the legacy of Syngman Rhee, the author shows what arguments conservatives and progressives make to defend their position, what tools and techniques they use to establish a certain interpretation of history as the dominant one. The reason for the dispute about the legacy of the fighters for Korean independence, who belonged to the left wing of the national liberation movement, was the decision of the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Korea to move the bust of Hong Beomdo, installed in front of the Military Academy, to another place. This decision caused protests from progressive political parties and public organizations, which accused the Yun Seokyeol’s government of an anti-communist approach and disdain for independence fighters. The dispute over Hong Beomdo’s bust also showed that there is no unity among conservatives on this issue. The government of Yun Seokyeol, largely, proceeds in its memory policies from the theoretical approach of the “new right,” the far-right group of the South Korean conservatives, which diminish the importance of anti-Japanese resistance, especially the left wing, in restoring Korean state sovereignty. At the same time, the “new right” proponents highly appreciates the role of the first President Syngman Rhee in the establishment of the Republic of Korea, ensuring its security and prosperity. The conservative government supports public initiatives to restore the positive image of Syngman Rhee, who resigned as a result of the 1960 April Revolution. Progressives have an extremely negative attitude towards conservative’s attempts to revive the legacy of Syngman Rhee, who was guilty of the presidential election fraud and political repressions.
About the authors
Natalia Nikolaevna Kim
Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences; Lomonosov Moscow State University
Author for correspondence.
Email: nkim@iaas.msu.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7728-7968
SPIN-code: 2804-0219
ResearcherId: J-8327-2015
Ph.D. in History, senior research fellow at the Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences, and director of the International Center for Korean Studies, Lomonosov Moscow State University
12 Rozhdestvenka St, Moscow, 107031, Russian Federation; 11/1 Mokhovaya St, Moscow, 125009, Russian FederationReferences
- Semyachko A. Politika pamyati: kak i zachem gosudarstva formiruyut svoyu istoriyu [Memory Politics: How and why states shape their history]. Available from: https://special.theoryandpractice.ru/politics-of-memory [Accessed: 07.11.2023] [In Russ.].
- Hong Beomdo. Encyclopedia of Korean culture. Available from: https://encykorea.aks.ac.kr/Article/E0064093 [Accessed: 28.10.2023] [In Korean].
- Pak V.K. Khon Bomdo — chelovek iz legendy [Hong Beomdo — a man from legend]. Available from: https://koryo-saram.site/hon-bomdo-chelovek-iz-legendy/) [Accessed: 28.10.2023] [In Russ.].
- Hongbeomdo hyungsang nollan, wae bulgeojyeonna? [Why did the Hong Beom-do bust controversy arise?]. KBS news, 2023, Aug 28. Available from: https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/pc/view/view.do?ncd=7759316 [Accessed: 28.10.2023] [In Korean].
- Gwon Hyeokcheol. Gukbangbu “gongsanjuui iryeong Hong Beomdo hyungsang, yuksae bujeokjeol” [Ministry of Defense “The bust of Hong Beomdo, who had a communist history, does not match to the Military Academy]. Hangyeore, 2023, Aug 28. Available from: https://www.hani.co.kr/arti/politics/politics_general/1106126.html [Accessed: 28.10.2023] [In Korean].
- Sin Juyeong. Minjudang, gukbangbu Hong Beomdo hyungsang cheolgeo chujine “cheol jinan saekkkallon maegung haengwi” [Democratic Party, Ministry of Defense’s push to remove Hong Beom-do’s bust: “Outdated ideology… treason against the country”]. Gyeonghyang sinmun, 2023, Aug 30. Available from: https://m.khan.co.kr/politics/politicsgeneral/article/202308301607011 [Accessed: 31.10.2023] [In Korean].
- Yu Hara. Hong Beomdo hyungsang ijeon, gukim naeeseodo bipan minju-jeongui, gangdo nopge bipan…Jeong Yulseong nollaneneun sogeukjeok [Regarding the Hong Beom-do bust’s removal, it was also criticized within the People’s Power party. Democracy and justice were strongly criticized… Passive approach to the Jeong Yulseong controversy]. www.rediang.org, 2023, Aug 28. Available from: http://www.redian.org/archive/173435 [Accessed: 31.10.2023] [In Korean].
- Jo Hyeonho. Hong Beomdo ijeon hyungsang ipjang jiruie chanban jeonghal ge anida neun gukim. [In response to questions about the Hong Beom-do’s bust, the People’s Power said, “It is not a matter of pros and cons”]. www.mediatoday, 2023, Sep 1. Available from: http://www.mediatoday.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=312243 (Accessed: 29.10.2023) [In Korean].
- Bae Jaeseong. I Junseok Hong Beomdo hyungsang ijeon nollane “jalhaneun geo haja, baekjihwa” [I Junseok responded to the controversy on the Hong Beomdo’s by saying, “Let’s do what we’re good at, make it a blank list”]. The JoongAng, 2023, Aug 29. Available from: https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25188212#home (Accessed: 29.10.2023) [In Korean].
- Ha Taewon. Joon gwangwanggaek? geureom seutallin, irwang ginyeomgongwon mandeulji [Chinese tourists? Then let’s make Stalin’s or Japanese emperor’s museum]. www. n.news.naver.com, 2023, Aug 23. Available from: https://n.news.naver.com/mnews/article/449/0000256131 (Accessed: 03.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Nyuraiteu (Daehanminguk) [New Right Movement (The Republic of Korea)]. Available from: https://namu.wiki (Accessed: 03.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Jeong Yongtaek. Singminsagwaneuro Hong Beomdo jangguneul yokdoege haji malla [Do not disgrace General Hong Beom-do with your colonialist approach]. www.educhang.co.kr, 2023, Sep 1. Available from: https://www.educhang.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=631 (Accessed: 04.11.2023) [In Korean].
- I Yeonghun gyosu, singminjigeundaehwaron, wianbu munje, MBCgija pokaeng nollan deunge daehan ipjang balkyeo [Professor I Yeonghun talks about his views on colonial modernization, “comfort women” and the attack on an MBC reporter]. www.m.monthly. chosun.com, 2019, Aug 16. Available from: http://m.monthly.chosun.com/client/mdaily/daily_view.asp?idx=7682&Newsnumb=2019087682 (Accessed: 04.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Kim Natalia N. Kritika teorii kolonial’noi modernizatsii Korei: podkhody i otsenki v sovremennoi yuzhnokoreiskoi istoriografii [The critics of the colonial modernization theory: approaches and assessments in the modern South Korean historiography]. Vostok (Oriens). 2014;(3):177–185 [In Russ.].
- Daean gyogwaseo hangukgeunhyeondaesa nollan [Controversy surrounding an alternative textbook on modern and contemporary Korean history]. Gyeonghyang sinmun, 2008, Apr Available from: https://m.khan.co.kr/article/200804011814405 (Accessed: 04.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Bosu-jinbohakgye hyeondaesa gyoyangseoro gyeokdol [Conservative and liberal academics clash over modern history textbooks]. www.v.daum.net, 2013, March 12. Available from: https://v.daum.net/v/20130312110315460 (Accessed: 04.11.2023) [In Korean].
- I Seungman daetongnyeongginyeomgwan geollibundong bongyeokwadoeda [The movement to build the President Syngman Rhee Museum begins in earnest]. The JoongAng, 2023, Sep 11. Available from: https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25191487#home (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- I Seungman ginyeomgwan, myeongbun-jangso nollan [Controversy over Syngman Rhee Museum’s cause and location]. Naeil Sinmun, 2023, Aug 14. Available from: https://m. naeil.com/m_news_view.php?id_art=470218 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- No Seokjo. I Seungman ginyeomgwan geollim wihae 3taega tteun moatda [Three generations came together to build the Syngman Rhee Museum]. Chosun Ilbo, 2023, Oct 5. Available from: https://www.chosun.com/politics/politics_general/2023/10/05/ZC3FMQ7ZYRDJ5H732PAXANDQAE/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Yang Jihye. I Seungmaneun gajang jongyeonghaneun daetongnyeong ‘yeomyeong 808’ Nam Jonghyeon hoejang 1eok gibu [“Rhee Syngman is the most respected president” ‘yeomyeong 808’ Chairman Nam Jonghyeon donates 100 million won]. Chosun Ilbo, 2023, Sep 27. Available from: https://www.chosun.com/politics/politics_general/2023/09/27/PIRNBL3MXBF3FHSPGNALWWIMMY/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- No Seokjo. Yuksa chongdongchanghoe, I Seungman ginyeomgwan geollibe 1eok gibu [Military Academy Alumni Association donates 100 million won to build Syngman Rhee Museum]. Chosun Ilbo, 2023, Sep 26. Available from: https://www.chosun.com/politics/diplomacydefense/2023/09/26/UP4VZSNCPBBBJDFZK357MSHSBY/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Yang Jihye. Honam chulsin gieobindeul, I Seungman ginyeomgwan geollibe dongcham [Entrepreneurs from Honam participate in the construction of the Syngman Rhee Museum]. Chosun Ilbo, 2023, Oct 6. Available from: https://www.chosun.com/politics/politics_ general/2023/10/06/BUZJOUQGJNGLHES2SMJXQC7BLM/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Gim Minseo. Jeondaetongnyeong adeuldeuldo mogeum dongchamhagiro [The former president’s sons also decided to participate in fundraising]. Chosun Ilbo, 2923, Sep Available from: https://www.chosun.com/politics/politics_general/2023/09/27/MNRY4KPBYFHXXPNNMIWVVC4IHY/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Choe Boran. Wollobaeu Sin Yeonggyun I Seungmanginyeomgwan wihae ttang 4000pyeong gibuhagetda [Veteran actor Shin Young-gyun “I will donate 4,000 pyeong of land for the Syngman Rhee Museum”]. Yonhap News, 2023, Jul 5. Available from: https://www.ytn.co.kr/_ln/0106_202307051038076486 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- I Seul. “Du ai eommaui baram” I Yeongae, I Seungman ginyeomgwan gibu nollan haemyeong [“Wish of a mother of two children”… I Yeongae explains controversy over donation to Syngman Rhee Museum]. www. namu.news, 2023, Oct 4. Available from: https://namu.news/article/2122805#gsc.tab=0 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- The Constitution of the Republic of Korea (1987). Available from: https://worldconstitutions.ru/?p=35 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Russ.].
- Daehanmingung heonbeop/ yeoksa [The Constitution of the Republic of Korea]. Available from: https://namu.wiki/ (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Jin Byeongtae, I Seunghyeong. Chilgok Dabudong jeonjeokginyeomgwane I Seungman- Teurumeon daetongnyeong dongsang jemak [Statues of Presidents Syngman Rhee and Truman unveiled at Chilgok Dabu-dong War Memorial]. Yonhap News, 2023, Jul 27. Available from: https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20230727053051053 (дата обращения: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Jeon Sanghu. Busan sonyeosang yeop Bak Jeonghui — I Seungman hyungsang seuryeoda musan [An attempt to erect busts of Park Chung-hee and Syngman Rhee next to the Peace Girl Statue in Busan failed]. Segye Ilbo, 2017, Apr 21. Available from: https://m.segye.com/view/20170421003167 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Gim Hyeona. Imsisudoginyeomgwan ap I Seungman dongsang isanghan cheolgeo [Strange removal of Syngman Rhee statue in front of Provisional Capital Museum]. Busan ilbo, 2014, Apr 11. Available from: https://www.busan.com/view/busan/view. php?code=20130706000030 (Accessed: 05.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Gim Hyeonsu. ‘Chinil’ Baek Seonyeop ieo I Seungman-Teurumeon dongsangkkaji Chilgok Dabudong jeonjeokginyeomgwan seolchi [Following ‘pro-Japanese’ Baek Seonyeop, statues of Syngman Rhee and Truman were installed at the Chilgok Dabu-dong War Museum]. Gyeonghyang sinmun, 2023, Jul 27. Available from: https://m.khan.co.kr/national/nationalgeneral/article/202307272204035 (Accessed: 06.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Jo Jaeyeon. I Seungman eopjeok jaepyeongga sok ‘gwanghwamune dongsang geollip’ chujinwi baljok [In the re-evaluation of Syngman Rhee’s achievements… ‘Erection of his statue in Gwanghwamun’ promotion committee launched]. Munhwa ilbo, 2023, Oct 12. Available from: https://munhwa.com/news/view.html?no=2023101201070430103001 (Accessed: 06.11.2023) [In Korean].
- Gwon Hyeokcheol. Daehanminguk wonnyeon nonjaeng “1919” vs “1948nyeon” [Controversy on the year of the foundation of the Republic of Korea…“1919” vs “1948”]. Hangyeore, 2023, Jul 5. Available from: https://www.hani.co.kr/arti/politics/politics_general/1098752. html (Accessed: 06.11.2023) [In Korean].