OBJECT OF TAXATION UNDER DIGITALIZATION

Cover Page

Cite item

Abstract

The article investigates the problem of content change of the concept object of taxation in the Russian tax law on the path to digital economy. The purpose of the article is to analyze the provisions of the Russian tax legislation, international norms, as well as academic literature devoted to identification of certain new goods and phenomena as possible objects of taxation, thus updating the concept of the object of taxation itself. The development of information technologies generates the following unavoidable problems related to the object of taxation concept content, which allows reviving the discussion about the content of this tax and legal category: the impossibility to assess implementation operations as potential tax objects with the help of the classical triad «product, work, service»; recognition in certain situations (for example, in case of electronic money payment) as the object of taxation is not one, but a set of legal facts (cause of action); the need to establish the object of taxation through the so-called «tax relationship» between the object and the subject of taxation. In connection with the first problem, the author proposes to unambiguously define in the Tax Code the legal nature of transactions with digital products for tax purposes, treating them as a new type of service. The conclusion is based on the experience of international regulation and suggests supplementing the provisions of the Tax Code in terms of legal regulation of the concept taxation object as well as VAT taxation. The re-search of the second problem leads to the conclusion that it is necessary to clarify the rules of the Tax Code when the counterparties carry out taxable transactions, whose settlements are made with electronic money. In this situation, the object of taxation is not single, but suggests several legal facts-actions of the potential tax-payer. On the third problem the author raises the issues of identification of the taxpayer in case of certifying the taxable transaction by the digital signature analogue. Taking into account international experience, as well as national civil law regulations, it is considered necessary to include provisions on digital certificates and digital signatures in tax legislation.

About the authors

Olga I. Lyutova

National Research University «Higher School of Economics»

Author for correspondence.
Email: olyutova@hse.ru

Candidate of Legal Sciences, researcher of the Institute of State and Municipal Management

11 Myasnitskaya srt., 101000, Moscow, Russian Federation

References

  1. Andreev, N.Yu. (2018) Tax Sovereignty and Digital Economy: Digital Permanent Representation. Financial Law. 12, 13–16. (in Russian).
  2. Belikov, E.G. (2019) Tendencies of the social and innovation-driven development of tax laws in the digital economy conditions. Taxes. 4, 23–26. (in Russian).
  3. Blazheev, V.V., Egorova, M.A. (eds.) (2020) Tsifrovoye pravo: uchebnik [Digital law: textbook]. Moscow: Prospect Publ. (in Russian).
  4. Bukach, E. (2017) The main directions of international taxation in the EAEU [Interview with N.T. Mambetaliev]. Tax Bulletin — Consultations. Explanations. Opinions. 9, 10–16 (in Russian).
  5. Cesarano, F. (2008) Money and monetary systems. Cambridge University Press.
  6. Churkin, A.V. (2002) The concept of the object of taxation and the problems of its definition in the legislation: Author. dis. ... cand. legal sciences. Moscow. (in Russian).
  7. Grishina, O.P. (2019) Oplata pokupatelem uslug svyazi cherez elektronnyi koshelek [Payment by the buyer of communication services through an electronic wallet]. Uslugi svyazi: bukhgalterskii uchet i nalogooblozhenie [Communication services: accounting and taxation]. 1, 21–27. (in Russian).
  8. Hampton, S. (2016) Undermining Bitcoin. Washington Journal of Law. Technology & Arts. Vol. 11, Iss. 4. 331–334.
  9. Ivlieva, M.F. (1997) K ponyatiyu naloga i ob"ekta nalogooblozheniya [To the concept of tax and the object of taxation]. Vestnik MGU. Seriya 11. Pravo [Bulletin of Moscow State University. Issue 11: Law]. 3, 37–39. (in Russian).
  10. Kadar, M. (2015) European Union competition law in the digital era. Zeitschrift fur Wettbewerbsrecht. No. 4. 342–368.
  11. Karagusova, G. (1994) Nalogi: sushchnost' i praktika ispol'zovaniya [Taxes: the nature and practice of use]. Almaty: Ekonomika Publ. (in Russian).
  12. Koroleva, L.P. (2019) Taxation of digital services: theory, international practice and domestic prerequisites. Economic and social changes: facts, trends, forecast. 12 (3), 91–106. (in Russian).
  13. Khabrieva, T.Ya. (2018) Law facing challenges of digital reality. Journal of Russian Law. 9, 5–16. (in Russian).
  14. Khavanova, I.A. (2017) Tax jurisdiction: a new reading. Financial law. 5, 34–38. (in Russian).
  15. Kucherov, I.I. (2009) The value of the subject and source of taxation for the legal construction of tax. Financial Law. 5, 2–5. (in Russian).
  16. Kucheryavenko, N.P. (2003) The object of the tax relationship and the object of taxation: the content and correlation of concepts. Financial Law. 3, 11–13. (in Russian).
  17. Lambooij, M. (2014) Retailers Directly Accepting Bitcoins: Tricky Tax Issues? Finance and Capital Markets (formerly Derivatives & Financial Instruments), Volume 16, No 3. 138–144.
  18. Lyutova, O.I. (2019) The legal personality of cryptocurrency market participants: new approaches. Taxes-Journal. 2, 40–42. (in Russian).
  19. Matsuura, J.H. (2016) Digital Currency: An International Legal and Regulatory Compliance Guide. Bentham Science Publishers. doi: 10.2174/97816810822331160101.
  20. Mitin, D.A. (2018) E-Commerce Taxation: Russian and European Experience. Taxes. 6, 36–39. (in Russian).
  21. Pepelyaev, S.G. (2001) Osnovy nalogovogo prava [Fundamentals of tax law]. Moscow, Yurist Publ. (in Russian).
  22. Pokrovskaya, N.N. (2016) Problemy nalogooblozheniya innovatsionnykh biznes-modelei v tsifrovoi ekonomike [Problems of taxation of innovative business models in the digital economy]. Russian Economy in the Context of Resource Constraints: a collection of scientific papers based on the results of a scientific and practical conference of young scientists at St. Petersburg State University of Economics. St. Petersburg: Publishing House of St. Petersburg State University. (in Russian).
  23. Porokhov, E.V. (2001) Teoriya nalogovykh obyazatel'stv: Uchebnoe posobie [Theory of Tax Obligations: A Training Manual]. Almaty, Jetı Jargı Publ. (in Russian).
  24. Savelyev, A.I. (2017) Cryptocurrencies in the system of objects of civil rights. Law. 8, 136 — 153. (in Russian). Савельев А.И. Криптовалюты в системе объектов гражданских прав // Закон. 2017. № 8. С. 136–153.
  25. Shaviro, D. (2014) The Economics of Tax Law. New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers.
  26. Tsindeliani, I.I. (ed.) (2019) Finansovoye pravo v usloviyakh razvitiya tsifrovoy ekonomiki: monografiya [Financial law in the development of the digital economy: monograph]. Moscow, Prospect Publ. (in Russian).
  27. Napso, M.D., Napso, M.B. (2019) X Perm Congress of Jurists «Modern Economics in the Legal Dimension». Lex Russica. 12, 152–165. (in Russian).
  28. Yermak, D. (2013) Is a Bitcoin a Real Currency? An Economic appraisal. NBER Working papers series. Cambridge, 2013, available at: http://www.nber.org/papers/w19747.pdf.
  29. Wiseman, S.A. (2016) Property or Currency? The Tax Dilemma behind Bitcoin. Utah Law Review. (2). 417–440.

Copyright (c) 2020 Lyutova O.I.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies