Problems of Interaction Between the Diplomatic Missions of the Ukrainian SSR and the RSFSR in Warsaw in the Process of Creating the USSR

封面

如何引用文章

详细

The article examines the most acute problems and their solutions in the relations between the diplomats of the RSFSR and the Ukrainian SSR in Poland during the establishment of the Soviet Union (1921-1923). The relevance of the study is due to the introduction of recently declassified archival documents into the scientific discourse, as well as the growing interest in the topic in connection with the centennial of the creation of the USSR. The purpose of the study is to reveal the previously silenced facts and problems that accompanied the work of the foreign policy departments of the Soviet republics up to the rigid centralization and regulation of their activities, which occurred in the second half of 1923. So far, the issues of interaction between the diplomatic departments of the Soviet republics have remained virtually unexplored in the Russian historiography. At the same time, researchers in other post-Soviet countries are undoubtedly interested in the subject, which is limited by the materials of mainly local archives. The work is based on the methods of comparative historical analysis. The source base is based on the previously classified documents of the Archive of Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, in particular, the correspondence of the RSFSR plenipotentiary representation with the central office of the People’s Commissariat for Foreign Affairs of the RSFSR in Moscow. As a result of the study, the author came to the conclusion that in 1921-1923 there were constant misunderstandings and conflict situations in the relations between the diplomatic missions of the RSFSR and the Ukrainian SSR operating in Warsaw. The higher officials in Moscow and Kharkov had to be constantly involved in their resolution. At the same time, it was not always possible to resolve disagreements and conflicts that arose promptly due to the lack of ready solutions in the specialized departments of the two republics. Many disagreements in the actions of Russian and Ukrainian diplomats reflected the numerous intra-party disputes over various issues of subordination and state structure that developed among the Bolsheviks who had won in Russia and Ukraine. The contradictions that arose, especially in the first stage of the establishment of diplomatic missions, were tried to be deepened and used for their own purposes by the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

作者简介

Sergey Sklyarov

MGIMO University

编辑信件的主要联系方式.
Email: redaktors@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-5691-4088
SPIN 代码: 9227-6149

PhD (History), Associate Professor, Department of International Relations and Foreign Policy of Russia

Moscow, Russian Federation

参考

  1. Averyanov, A. V. (2019). The phenomenon of national policy in the USSR: Formation and development peculiarities in 1917–1930. Humanities and Law Research, (1), 8–14. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.37494/2409-1030-2019-1-8-14; EDN: OAIHGK
  2. Baranouski, A. V. (2018). Return of Vitsebsk province to the BSSR (the position of the provincial authorities). In A. D. Karol (Ed.), Formation of Belarusian statehood in the conditions of geopolitical shifts of the 20th century: Materials of the international science conference, Minsk, November 29–30, 2018 (pp. 39–44). Minsk: BSU publ. (In Belarusian). EDN: PHLELQ
  3. Belyavtseva, D. V. (2023). Projects for the Creation of the USSR: The choice between the federation and the regional state. In N. A. Antanovich (Ed.), To the 100th anniversary of the formation of the USSR: Lessons from history: Materials of the round table of the Department of Political Science of Faculty of Law of Belarusian State University, Minsk, December 15, 2022 (pp. 18–23). Minsk: BSU publ. (In Russian).
  4. Biyushkina, N. I. (2022). USSR education projects: Controversial problems of definition and expert assessments. Yuridicheskaya Tekhnika, (16), 83–87. (In Russian). EDN: PBNNMI
  5. Borisenok, E. Yu. (2005). Ukraine and Russia: Dispute over borders in the 1920s. In L. E. Gorizontov (Ed.), Regions and borders of Ukraine in historical retrospect (pp. 205–237). Moscow: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN publ. (In Russian). EDN: ZIKMTP
  6. Boyechko, V. D. (1991). Borders of Ukraine: History and problems of formation (1917–1940). Ukrainian Historical Journal, (1), 56–77. (In Ukrainian).
  7. Boyechko, V. D., Ganzha, O. I., & Zakharchuk, B. I. (1994). Borders of Ukraine: Historical retrospective and current state. Kiev: Osnovy publ. (In Ukrainian).
  8. Hasanli, Ja. (2011). How the Caucasian Bureau of the CC RCP (b) discussed the Karabakh issue in 1920–1923. The Caucasus & Globalization, 5(1–2), 139–170. (In Russian). EDN: QJCLXX
  9. Jezhula, A. O. (1965). From the history of Ukrainian-Polish economic relations (1920–1922). Soviet-Polish relations in 1919–1920. Questions of New and Recent History, (2), 25–40. (In Ukrainian).
  10. Khomich, S. (2000). The main stages of the formation of the territory of the BSSR (1918–1926). Belarusian Historical Review, 7(2), 351–364. (In Belarusian).
  11. Korotkova, D. (2018). “Enlargement of the Byelorussian SSR” in 1923–1924 as a factor of the Soviet influence in Poland. Slavianovedenie, (5), 48–59. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.31857/S0869544X0000850-8; EDN: YNRRCH
  12. Kulichenko, M. I. (1973). On the establishment of state relations between the peoples of the country of the Soviets in 1917–1919. In Yu. S. Tokarev (Ed.), Problems of state construction in the first years of Soviet power (pp. 96–118). Leningrad: Nauka publ. (In Russian).
  13. Kupchik, O. (2015). Democratic states and soviet republics of post-Russian imperial space in establishment of official relations with Soviet Ukraine in 1919–1923. European Historical Studies, (2), 200–215. (In Ukrainian).
  14. Kupchik, O. R. (2010). Participation of the Ukrainian SSR in Soviet foreign policy in the context of the creation of the USSR (1922–1923). Revista de Istorie a Moldovei, (3–4), 242–256. (In Russian).
  15. Matveev, G. F. (2010a). “Money in exchange for expulsion.” From the history of the Soviet-Polish diplomatic conflict in 1921. In K. V. Nikiforov (Ed.), Slavism dissolved in blood... In honor of the 80th anniversary of the birth of Vladimir Konstantinovich Volkov (1930–2005): Collection of articles (pp. 198–216). Moscow: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN publ. (In Russian).
  16. Matveev, G. F. (2010b). Beginning. In A. V. Torkunov, A. D. Rotfeld & M. M. Narinsky (Eds.), White spots — black spots: Complex issues in Russian-Polish relations (pp. 15–50). Moscow: Aspect Press publ. (In Russian).
  17. Matyash, I. B. (2016). Ukrainian consular service 1917–1923 as a state institution: Formation, functioning, personnel. Kiev: Іnstitut іstorіi Ukrainy publ. (In Ukrainian).
  18. Mustafaeva, S. (2010). Soviet Russia and the formation of borders between the Caucasian states (based on a case study of Azerbaijan and Armenia). The Caucasus & Globalization, 4(1–2), 230–240. (In Russian). EDN: QIUIDT
  19. Raychеnok, A. A. (2018). Problems of Belarusian statehood before the first years of education of the USSR. Proceedings of BSTU. Issue 6, History, Philosophy, (1), 42–46. (In Russian). EDN: XUTLTF
  20. Rubliov, O., & Gorburov, K. (2017). From the Peace of Riga to the “Molotov — Ribbentrop Pact”: To the history of diplomatic relations of the Ukrainian SSR with the Second Commonwealth. In M. Lytvyn (Ed.), Ukrainian-Polish relations. New age (pp. 177–221.). Lvov: Natsional’naya akademiya nauk Ukrainy, Institut ukrainovedeniya im. I. Krip’yakevicha publ. (In Ukrainian).
  21. Sakharov, V. A. (2012). The Union of the Soviet Republics or the Union of the Soviet peoples? Klio, (6), 122–132. (In Russian). EDN: OZCVKR
  22. Sokyrska, V. V. (2018). Relations between the RSFSR and the USSR (1919–1929): Political-economic and administrative-territorial discourse [thesis]. Uman; Ternopol. (In Ukrainian).
  23. Vdovin, A. I. (2018). The USSR. History of a great power (1922–1991). Moscow: Prospekt publ. (In Russian). EDN: NECSMN
  24. Yefimenko, H. (2012). The status of the USSR and its relations with the RSFSR: The long year of 1920. Kiev: Іnstitut іstorіi Ukrainy publ. (In Ukrainian).

版权所有 © Sklyarov S., 2024

Creative Commons License
此作品已接受知识共享署名-非商业性使用 4.0国际许可协议的许可。

##common.cookie##