“Love for the Fatherland” and civil Identity in the discourse of Latin and Greek inscriptions
- Authors: Makhlaiuk A.V.1
-
Affiliations:
- Lobachevsky National Research State University of Nizhny Novgorod
- Issue: Vol 14, No 3 (2022): Social Life of the Ancient World
- Pages: 308-327
- Section: THE CIVIC IDENTITY OF THE ROMAN WORLD
- URL: https://journals.rudn.ru/world-history/article/view/31953
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2312-8127-2022-14-3-308-327
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
Based on Greek and Latin epigraphy, the article examines the main features of civil ideology associated with the concept of “love of the fatherland” ( philopatria , amor patriae and their derivatives). The corresponding categories, often emotionally colored, were widely used to characterize the virtues and behavioral motives of urban elites who acted as euergetai . The lexical and contextual analysis of the inscriptions shows that the civic patriotism of the Greek cities coexisted quite well with the political loyalty to the Roman authorities and ruling emperors. In both Greek and Latin inscriptions, there is an explicit or implicit imperial context. In the former, it is especially emphasized by title names indicating “love” for emperors and Rome (φιλόκαισαρ, φιλοσέβαστος, φιλορώμαιος). In the western provinces and Italy, there was obviously no particular need for such direct references. It is reasonable to believe that there, in urban communities consisting of Roman citizens, a sense of belonging to two homelands, as Cicero defined them, remained: Rome as communis patria / patria civitatis (iuris) and the fatherland by nature and locality ( patria naturae / loci patria ). In other aspects, however, a comparison of the discourses of Greek and Latin inscriptions reveals direct parallels and coincidences in the basic value orientations, due to the remaining civil-communal (polis) character of the cities of the Roman Empire.
About the authors
Alexander Valentinovich Makhlaiuk
Lobachevsky National Research State University of Nizhny Novgorod
Author for correspondence.
Email: makhl@imomi.unn.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-7758-2374
Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Chair of the Department of Ancient and Medieval History of the Institute of International Relations and World History
23, Gagarin Ave., Nizhny Novgorod, Russia, 603950References
- Makhlaiuk AV. Institut grazhdanstva v Rimskoj imperii: obzor sovremennoj istoriografii [Institute of citizenship in the Roman Empire: a review of modern historiography]. In: Economics, law, power in the ancient world. Dedicated to the memory of V.I. Kuzishchin. Saprykin SYu, Gvozdeva IA, editors. St. Petersburg, 2021, p. 626–657. (In Russ.).
- Cecchet L. Introduction. Greek and Roman Citizenship: State of Research and Open questions. In: Citizens in the Graeco-Roman World. Aspects of Citizenship from the Archaic Period to AD 212. L. Cecchet, A. Busetto (eds.). Leiden; Boston, 2017, p. 1–30.
- Atkins JD. Citizenship and Civic Virtue. In: Roman Political Thought. J.D. Atkins 9ed.). Cambridge, 2018, p. 63–90.
- Moatti Cl. Occidere pro patria: quelques réflexions sur le patriotism. Anabasis. 2010;(12):137–147.
- Speidel MA. Pro patria mori… La doctrine du patriotisme romain dans l’armée impériale. Cahieres Glotz. 2010;(21):139–154.
- Ando C. Local Citizenship and Civic Participation in the Western Provinces of the Roman Empire. In: Civic Identity and Civic Participation in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages. C. Brélaz, E. Rose (eds.). Turnhout, 2021, p. 39–63.
- Brélaz C. Democracy, Citizenship(s), and ‘Patriotism’: Civic Practices and Discourses in the Greek Cities under Roman Rule. In: Civic Identity and Civic Participation in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages. C. Brélaz, E. Rose (eds.). Turnhout, 2021, p. 65–90.
- Veyne P. Panem et circenses: l’évergétisme devant les sciences humaines. Annales E.S.C. 1969;(14): 785–825.
- Veyne P. Le pain et le cirque: Sociologie historique d’un pluralisme politique. Paris, 1976.
- Van Nijf O. Civic Mirrors: Honorific Inscriptions and the Politics of Prestige. In: Social Status and Prestige in the Graeco-Roman World. A. Kuhn 9ed. Stuttgart, 2015, p. 233–246.
- Wörrle M. Vom tugendsamen Jungling zum ‘gestresten’ Euergeten. Uberlegungen zum Burgerbild hellenistischer Ehrendekrete. In: Stadtbild und Bürgerbild im Hellenismus. Kolloquium, München 24.–26. Juni 1993. M. Wörrle, P. Zanker (Hrsg.). München, 1995, p. 241–250.
- Makhlaiuk AV. Rimskij patriotizm i kul’turnaya identichnost’ v epohu Imperii [Roman patriotism and cultural identity under the Empire]. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo. 2014;1(1):288–299. (In Russ.).
- Makhlaiuk AV. Grecheskij patriotizm v kontekste pax Romana: polisnye tradicii i imperskie realii [Greek patriotism in the context of pax Romana: polis tradutuions and imperial realities]. Mnemon. 2018;18(2): 116–141. (In Russ.).
- Makhlaiuk AV. Vtoraya sofistika, istoricheskaya pamyat’ i grecheskij patriotizm v epohu Rimskoj imperii [Second sophistic, historical memory and Greek patriotism under the Roman empire]. In: Homo omnium horarum: sbornik statej v chest’ 70-letiya A.V. Podosinova. Belousov AV, Ilyushechkina EV, editors. M., 2020, p. 370–401. (In Russ.).
- Crowley J. Greek Patriotism. In: Handbook of Patriotism. Mitja Sardoč (ed.). Cham, 2020, p. 29–46.
- Giardina A. Amor Civicus. Formule e immagini dell’evergetismo Romano nella tradizione epigrafica. In: La terza età dell’ epigrafia. Colloquio AIEGL-Borghesi 86, Bologna ottobre 1986. A. Donati (ed.). Faenza, 1988, p. 67–85.
- Gascó F. Euergetes philopatris. In: Modelos ideales y practicas de vida en la antigüedad clasica. E. Falque, F. Gascó (eds.). Sevilla, 1993, p. 181–195.
- Le Roux P. L’amor patriae dans les cites sous l’empire romain. In: Idéologies et valeurs civiques dans le monde romain: hommage à Claude Lepelley [actes d’un colloque tenu à Paris les 25 et 26 septembre 2001]. H. Inglebert (ed.). Paris, 2002, p. 143–161.
- Forbis E. Municipal Virtues in the Roman Empire: The Evidence of Italian Honorary Inscriptions. Stuttgart; Leipzig, 1996 (reprinted De Gruyter, 2012).
- Montagne G. Amator civitatis: les notables municipaux en Numidie romaine (IIème — IVème siècle). Mémoire de master 2. l’Université de Pau et des Pays de l’Adour avec mention TB, 2013.
- Eckhard S. Honoratioren, Griechen, Polisbürger: Kollektive Identitäten innerhalb der Oberschicht des kaiserzeitlichen Kleinasien. Göttingen, 2002.
- Canali De Rossi F. Filius publicus, υἱὸς τῆς πόλεως e titoli affini in inscrizioni greche di età impériale. Roma, 2007.
- The Politics of Honour in the Greek Cities of the Roman Empire. A. Heller, O. Van Nijf (eds.). Leiden; Boston, 2017.
- Siekierka P., Stebnicka K., Wolicki A. Women and the Polis: Public Honorific Inscriptions for Women in the Greek Cities from the Late Classical to the Roman Period. Vol. 1. Berlin; Boston, 2021.
- Heller A. L’âge d’or des bienfaiteurs. Titres honorifiques et sociétés civiques dans l’Asie Mineure d’époque romaine (Ier s. av. J.-C. — IIIe s. apr. J.-C.). Genève, 2020.
- Veligianni Chr. Philos und philos-Komposita in den griechischen Inschriften der Kaiserzeit. In: Aspects of Friendship in the Graeco-Roman World (Proceedings of a conference held at the Seminar für Alte Geschichte, Heidelberg, on 10–11 June, 2000). M. Peachin (ed.). Portsmouth, 2001, p. 63–80.
- Giannakopoulos N. Remarks on the Honorary Titles υἱός βουλής, υἱός δήμου and υἱός πόλεως in Roman Asia Minor. In: Pathways to Power: Civic Elites in the Eastern Part of the Roman Empire. Proceedings of the International Workshop held at Athens Scuola Archeologica Italiana di Atene in December 2005. A.D. Rizakis, F. Camia (eds.). Atene, 2008, p. 251–268.
- Van Nijf O. Affective Politics: The Emotional Regime in the Imperial Greek City. In: Unveiling emotions II: Emotions in Greece and Rome. Texts, Images, Material Culture. A. Chaniotis, P. Ducrey (eds.). Stuttgart, 2013, p. 351–368.
- Pleket HW. Political Culture and Political Practice in the Cities of Asia Minor in the Roman Empire. In: Politische Theorie und Praxis im Altertum. W. Schuller (Hrsg.). Darmstadt, 1998, p. 204–216.
- Corbier M. Usages publics du vocabulaire de la parenté. In: L’Africa Romana. Atti del VII Convegno di Studio (Sassari, 15–17 dicembre 1989). A. Mastino (ed.). Sassari, 1990, p. 817–854.
- Fernoux H.-L. Le demos et la cité: communautés et assemblées populaires en Asie mineure à l’époque imperial. Rennes, 2011.
- Robert L. Hellenica. Vol. XIII. D’Aphrodisias à la Lyca. Recueil d’épigraphie, de numismatique et d’antiquités. Paris, 1965.
- Oppeneer T. Assembly Politics and the Rhetoric of Honour in Chariton, Dio of Prusa and John Chrysostom. Historia. 2018;67(2):223–243.
- Kuhn CT. Emotionality in the Political Culture of the Graeco-Roman East: The Role of Acclamations. In: Unveiling Emotions: Sources and Methods for the Study of Emotions in the Greek World. A. Chaniotis (ed.). Stuttgart, 2012, p. 295–316.
- Kruse T. The Magistrate and the Ocean: Acclamations and Ritualised Communication in Town Gatherings in Roman Egypt. In: Rituals and Communication in the Graeco-Roman World. E. Stavrianopoulou (ed.). Liège, 2006, p. 297–315.
- Mitchell S. Festivals, games, and civic life in Roman Asia Minor. Journal of Roman Studies. 1990;(80): 183–193.
- Wörrle M. Stadt und Fest im kaiserzeitlichen Kleinasien: Studien zu einer agonistischen Stiftung aus Oinoanda. München, 1988.
- Rogers G.M. Demosthenes of Oenoanda and models of euergetism. Journal of Roman Studies. 1991;(8)1:91–100.
- Kokkinia C. Die Opramoas-Inschrift von Rhodiapolis. Euergetismus und soziale Elite in Lykien. Bonn, 2000.
- Buraselis K. Kos between Hellenism and Rome. Studies on the Political, Institutional and Social History of Kos from ca. the Middle Second Century B.C. Until Late Antiquity. Philadelphia, 2000.
- Gascό F. Evergetismo y conciencia cίvica en la parte oriental del imperio. Habis. 1995;(26): 177–186.
- van Nijf O.M. Public space and the political culture of Roman Termessos. In: Political culture in Greek city after the Classical age. O.M. van Nijf and R. Alston (eds.). Leuven; Paris; Walpole, MA, 2011, p. 215–242.